Rhinoplasty: Stories

Write a Review

Unhappy with Intial Results, Now Facing More Uncertainty with Upcoming Revision

  • unregistered guest
  • posted 5 years ago
  • updated 5 years ago
  • Not Worth It
  • Cost: $5,500
  • Rochester, NY

I had an open rhinoplasty last December to correct...

I had an open rhinoplasty last December to correct a bulbous tip and generally large nose. The surgeon I selected assured me that my goal for my nose--which I illustrated using Photoshop--was both realistic and attainable. Surgery was fine; I felt no pain during. When I awoke after 3 hours of surgery--an hour and a half longer then expected--I was very uncomfortable, but not in a large amount of pain. My nose bled for about 4 hours and my face, especially eyes and cheek, blew up. I was very swollen and bruised for about 7 days. Recovery was a debacle. About 4 days after surgery, I went to the E.R. It was sooo painful to swallow and I hadn't been able to eat anything. I thought maybe the breathing tube used during surgery scratched the back of my throat? They never figured out what was causing all the pain--worst pain I've ever felt! went to the hospital finally after breaking down in tears! It went away after about a week. I had something called 'dissolvable' packing in my nose, which sounded very nice (I wouldn't have to go back to see the Dr. to have the packing removed). Unfortunately, the packing was hardly dissolvable and took a very long time to come out! The cast came off on the 7th day and my nose looked swollen and 'poofy.' The Dr. said that the majority of the swelling would subside and I would be very pleased with the thinner, less protruding nose underneath. Six months later my nose looked almost exactly the same as it did prior to surgery, but with an ugly scar on my 'columna' and an assymetrical interior that was very noticable--deviated septum, from a broken sutre. I was very relieved to hear that the Dr., too, was unhappy with my result and did not dispute any of my disatifaction. We decided to do the revision a year from the original surgery date. The Dr. would charge no surgeon's fee, but I would have to pay for the facility and anethesia--an additional $2,000 after already paying $5,500. The Dr. says he will be using a different surgical approach this time--removing sections of cartilage and sewing the remaining parts back together. This sounds like a nightmare, but I didn't spend so much money to have the same nose. I'm scared, but hoping for the best!!
Great review?

Comments (13)

Sort by
miche 1 Dec 2010
wish thats all i had paid... hahaha , these doctors are such rip off scam artist .... They are worse than the common criminal , and they get paid good money to rip us off... REALLY? I think someone needs to evaluate them a little more before they go out in the world and start jacking with peoples lives...
rochester 9 Jan 2010
Kathleen, if you could share with me the doctor you used that would be great. Also would love to hear from anyone with rochester nose job experience, good or bad.
mm21 19 Jul 2009
Yes, I did too, but now am considering blepharoplasty on upper lids only. Someone told me they would only do this with an ocular plastic surgeon. Very nervous. I don't want to look asian or too pulled but have that extra fold. (50 yr-)
mm21 17 Jul 2009
I am considering a blepharoplasty and need all the help I can get choosing a plastic surgeon. I am also in Rochester and so a name would really be helpful/ (They don't know who you are anyway and you are anonymous here).
Mistyws 8 May 2009
I'd love to know who your surgeon was. As i am also considering a Rochester surgeon. Please send me a message?
awalk 5 Apr 2009
Tip Rhinoplasty is challenging..Dr.Thomas Hubbard in Virginia Beach specializes in this and did a wonderful job on my friend’s revision... Best Wishes I would like to add I have watched several friends get nose jobs the most successful of those where when they asked for the surgeons input and suggestions.. As opposed to requesting a nose from a picture.. It is much better to look at before/afters of similiar noses for the correction you are considering and showing him what you don’t like from their result.. These surgeons spend years studying standards of beauty in relation to proportion and measurements of the face.. While you may want a certain nose it’s wise to take the surgeons advice as to what is going to get you closer to this standard… It’s all our parts put together correctly that make us attractive,, Not a particular nose ect..
Jam87 19 Dec 2008
who was your doctor? I'm planning on getting one in Rochester soon also and don't want this wacko.
Tangosmom 21 Nov 2008
Rhinoplasty Surgery was done just a week ago. The swelling and bruising are HORRIBLE, painful sore throat was unexpected. I had the cast off yesturday and for a week out feel that it looks good. ( will look better once the swelling goes down) My biggest problem is that is really hurts to swallow. The pain of my throat wakes me up even when I take a sleeping pill. My Dr, said the pain is from all the dripping down the back of my throat. I am going to get a throat spray to see if it helps. The recovery was harder then I thought it would be.
junelle 16 Oct 2008
Katie who was your dr in san diego i want to have a revision. I want to shorten it and want it small. I live in az and cant seem to find a surgeon i think does nice work If you can send me his name id so apprecate it junelle
katie1992 2 Oct 2008
Definitely get your nose re-done! I had to go through two rhinoplasties as well. My first one looked terrible and no one wanted to tell me. They only told me after I got my second one. The second one isn't as bad b/c you know what to expect. I don't know if I would go to the same doctor. My doctor charged me $4500 LA/San Diego area for the rhinoplasty and $500 for the revision, plus he threw in some botox. I do think $2000 is a lot to pay for your revision of the doctor agrees that he messed up. $500 is generally the fee and my doctor kind of "waived" that by giving me complimentary botox . If you are in the SD/LA area and want a reasonable doctor, I would be happy to recommend mine, but only privately b/c I am announcing here that I had to get a re-do. The issue with me and my doctor was that he thought I wanted to preserve my nose more than I actually did, so he did minimal work and I was disappointed b/c I wanted a tiny nose. So the second time around, I said make it as small as possible and that's what he did. :) My doctor was attentive though and called personally to make sure I was okay the day after both procedures. I also have had him do my lips and they look great- I get tons of compliments. His botox is so great no one notices I've had anything done! He is also a board certified ENT so his procedure helped all alergies,etc. With proper communication, this guy is the best. :) Katie
C 21 Jun 2008
I had a similar experience. I had a rhynoplasty in December 2004, and the results were not as expected as my surgeon straightened the upper half of my nose, and not the tip - which looked hideous! I kept the same hideous nose for almost 3.5 years, until this week I had the correction done. My recommendation to anyone considering this - make sure you ask questions about how the results will look, because it is stupid and painful to go into surgery twice when it could have been eliminated the first time around. If your doctor is stubborn, change doctors....you have every right as a patient to ask questions, and ensure the doctor you are using is experienced! i mean it! I think my doctor was just starting when I did my initial procedure...ugh... Anyways, im still bandaged up, but going in on Monday to have it removed, and its no more plastic surgery for me...for life.
nugenose33 18 Jul 2008
Hello, I was also thinking of gettin a rhinoplasty in rochester NY... what doctor did you have so I can avoid him? Editor note: You must be contacted privately to receive the information you requested. This requires free registration for an account. When registering, you must opt-in to receive private messages (a check box).
jason haq (unregistered guest) 3 Feb 2008
Hey hello: I hope that you get the nose you want. I am also considering rhino. I also have a bulbuous tip and would like to get it corrected. Can u kindly share some pictures of urself. ? I will eb grateful. thanks J

Update your review

Welcome Back

Sign in with Facebook

Your information remains private and will not be posted without your permission.

Forgot your password?

Don't have an account? Create one now.

Join RealSelf

Join with Facebook

Your information remains private and will not be posted without your permission.

Please enter a valid email address
 Did you mean ?

By creating an account, you are indicating that you have read and accept the RealSelf Terms of Use.

Already a member? Sign In.

Retrieve your password

Enter your username or email address and we will send you a link to login.

Check your email

Check your email. We've sent you a link to reset your password.

Ok