Hair Transplant Reviews
77%
WORTH IT RATING
"Worth It Rating" shows the % of consumer reviewers that stated the procedure was "Worth It" or not. See more RealSelf Worth It Ratings or Add Your Review
Hair Transplantbefore & after photos
View Before and Afters

Average Hair Transplant Cost: $12,336

Learn about Hair Transplant

230 people and 82 doctors are talking about Hair Transplant

Get Free Email Updates

Hair Transplant Nightmare

Not Worth It
Spent: $40,000 in Cleveland, Ohio / Alpharetta, GA

Comments (54)

Updated 26 Dec 2009

Posted 18 Apr 2009

Please don't get this procedure done it has permanently scared HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of patients in the last 40 years and ruined so many lives. Don't believe clinics that tell you "that was the old plug transplants but now there are new and improved procedures"

  • You will be left with an ear to ear linear scar on the back of your head ( from a strip procedure), where the hair grafts are taken from, and redness and bumps where the grafts are placed on top of your head.
  • If you get the newer FUE procedure you will have little white scars all over the donor area and little red bumps where the grafts were placed. I have had both types of procedures done. It will never look 100% natural.
  • Don't believe the pictures they show you, these pictures are taken in a controlled environment under certain lighting with hair combed a particular way. Unfortunately we don't live our lives in a controlled environment and wind, rain, strong indoor lighting, and the sun will show that you had a transplant no matter how good the Dr. is.

I had my work done with one of the top Doctors in the country. It can and has ruined too many lives. I am in the process of getting all the transplanted hair lasered out after suffering for almost 10 years now and spending over $40,000. I am also having the fraxel restore done to smooth out the area.

I once thought losing my hair was a big deal now I envy bald people with a normal scar free shaved head. It was by far and away the worst mistake of my life, don't be the next victim. Just do a google search on "bad hair transplants" and remember these are from old AND new transplant procedures being done today, even though the doctors will try and convince you otherwise. It will look unnatural and leave you permanently scarred for life. 

This review is the subjective opinion of a RealSelf member and not of RealSelf, Inc.

Helpful review?

Comments (54)

Post a Comment Sort:
Fred Barnes 11 May 2009
This person obviously had a bad experience. I have had a hair transplant and the results are nothing short of amazing. I have no "red-dots" or bumps where the grafts were placed. Of course I have a thin scar on the back of my head, but every single surgery creates scars. The scar is in the hair, and I have short hair, and it doesn't show at all. I look easily 15 years younger, and I am able to date women that are on average 10 years younger now than before I had my hair replaced. I had the procedure done after my brother had it done, and we're both thrilled. It wasn't painful at all, and was about as intense as having my teeth cleaned. I would recommend a visit to a hair restoration surgeon to check things out as a start. To say that it's categorically a "nightmare" is just not true. At all.
Understand 13 May 2009
OK if it's not true why when you do a simple search on yahoo.com with "hair transplant repair" in quotation marks do you get 338,000 hits! Do a search and look at the pictures for yourself and the truth will become readily apparent of the lives that have been ruined. The scar it leaves can be very red and 12 inches across and one-half an inch wide, mine is. This is NOT a simple procedure don't be fooled and learn the hard way, once the damage is done it cannot be undone. There are forums on the internet with literally thousands of people desperate for repair who's lives have been ruined by these procedures. They have "cobblestoning", raised bumps where the grafts were not placed deep enough in the scalp. Pitting, indentations where the graphs were placed too deep in the scalp. Ridging along the hairline, where a large area is raised above the surrounding skin demarcating where the grafts were placed. Unnatural results that are pluggy "doll-like-hair". The list goes on and on. Many try to get the grafts excised or the hair lasered out to reduce the "tell-tale" signs of the hair transplant, but then the large scar on the back of their head is more apparent as is the cobblestoning/pitting/ridging effect. There are many doctors who's major clientele are hair transplant repair patients. Wow its unbelievable that these procedures are still being done. If I can save one person from avoiding the mistakes we made when we were young and impressionable then it's worth my time. Remember some of these people posting on here might be in the hair transplant industry and trying to promote these procedures because they have a vested interest in keeping the truth out.
bmark 30 Sep 2010
Fred, Care to share the name of the doctor you and your brother used? I want to get a procedure and I visited Bosley, but I realize now that it is more important to pick a doctor that has shown proven results. Please help me out.
tonymia 20 May 2009
I think you represent an unfortunate monirity of people who have had a very bad transplant. I have been on those forums and I believe Cole if it is the same doctor is known as giving poor results. Good luck to you but we all see what we want to see on the internet.
Understand 24 May 2009
Mia just out of curiosity, what in your life experience makes you say I’m in the "unfortunate minority" of people having a bad transplant? How would you know this Dr. Cole from that Dr. Cole? No offence but it sounds like you are from this very industry I’m trying to warn people about. Just be honest. This is definitely not the same Dr. Cole you are thinking of this is Dr.John P. Cole located in Alpharetta, GA. he is a well respected top notch transplant surgeon. However, the problem is the surgery itself is fundamentally flawed. When a strip of donor hair is taken from the back of your head you have a scar where the hair was taken from and no hair grows there anymore. As you have more surgeries this gap becomes much wider due to decreased scalp laxity. Eventually you cannot have further surgeries because the scalp is too tight. Now you have a exaggerated wide scar on the back of your head that you cannot cover with your existing hair and the donor is "tapped-out". So your left with extensive scarring and you are still losing hair so the transplanted hair stands out and is more obvious as a transplant. Why would someone want to take all this risk and complicate their lives?
tonymia 25 May 2009

okay..so it sounds like your top notch surgeon (I guess not the well known dr) didnt plan properly with the limited donor supply. Part of the hair trans[plant process is to realize what you can and cannot cover with your limited donor..you should never be in a position where you are "outa hair" and need more. the truth is..if it was so bad the industry itself regardless of advertising would implode as it ran out of customers. But it hasnt, and people do go back for more surgeries. Granted any surgery isnt going to be perfect ect. but seems to me common sense would dictate if it was so horrible eventually no one would be going. your story should be giventhe credence it deserves..just as the good stories do. Sorry to hear your situation but please keep it in perspective too...there are many people without arms, legs, eyes, dying of cancer ect who would switch lives with you! uh, no...just beucase I dont share your opinion doesnt mean I work in the industry.

Understand 26 May 2009
The industry does not implode because there is a constant supply of people that don't realize what a surgery like this involves, they are sold on a false dream. I can show you transplants preformed in the 70's, 80's, and 90's where cookie type cutters the size of a dime where used to punch holes in patients scalps with up to 100 hairs per graft. These holes were left gapping and oozing and the patient was wrapped up and sent home. There is even a name for it in the industry "open donor" these people have obviously been seriously scared with corn-row transplants to boot. Why would a patient knowingly have a scalp reduction when it causes extensive scarring and the skin eventually stretches back and leaves atrocious scarring that causes serious scalp deformity. Why did/do the patients keep coming? They trusted the advertising and the doctors who showed them the glossy pictures and didn’t tell them the repercussions/implications. Come on lets be honest most of these doctors played on peoples insecurities and maliciously ruined people lives knowingly to make a buck. That’s the sad truth. I am studying to be a nurse and for the life of me I can’t understand stand how a medical doctor can do this for money. I wouldn’t ruin someone’s life for any amount of money, maybe I am weird I don’t know. But alas the patients kept coming because they didn’t meet the last guy who's life was ruined. How could they he is now hiding under a hat or hair piece or doesn’t leave the house and has cut contact with family and friends. Sounds extreme but it’s the truth…… you would do the same thing if you had an obvious hair transplant. The industry survives by a combination of desperate younger naive patients and doctors who are not completely honest and downplay the pitfalls. If doctors didn’t there is a good chance people would not have the surgery done. Sure people will have a series of surgeries done because it is a short term "fix" but once they continue to lose hair they will realize the scarring that has been done that the hair was semi-covering. This cycle has already happened to thousands and thousands of patients. How can a doctor do a series of hair transplants on a youngish patient when they cannot predict what the extent of future loss will be and the donor and scalp laxity is limited....it doesn’t add up. Actually my situation is not bad at all compared to a lot of others, their lives are for all intents and purposes is ruined. How can they live a normal life when they have an obvious hair transplant, they are humiliated. A person without arms or legs is worse off for sure but there is nothing as humiliating as a person with an obvious transplant that people stare at all day and whisper about behind their backs and snicker at. You don't know because it didn’t happen to you so it's not such a big deal. Trust me if you were in there situation you would feel totally different. I don't want another naive desperate young person to risk ruining their lives based on a false dream painted by a malicious industry and unscrupulous doctors . I truly hope this industry and these doctors are proud of themselves and enjoy the money they have made.
7760anon 16 Aug 2010
O M G - you want revenge, don't you? Every operation has good and bad results. You are TOLD about the risks well beforehand. You can accept them, or refuse them. Every body has a different response to operations. Some people cannot accept the fact that they are (getting) bold, and will do whatever it takes to have an operation done - EVEN when the dr. tells them that 6.000 hairs will not make a HUGE difference on a nearly bold head. At the gym I go to I have seen quite a few guys with THE JOB done. I rarely see the big scar you are referring to, nor the tiny white scars. And red bumps??? Nope .... Most of them are very happy with the result. That is all that counts. Whether I like it or not is totally irrelevant. THEY like it, and THEY consider it worth the money. By the way, I am the only male in the family who is not bold. And yes, we're from the same parents ;-) I have been standing on my head since the age of 7, use food supplements and massage my head twice a day. Since last year I also use Finasteride. If I need to do this for the rest of my life (I'm 62, so maybe another 30 years) I will happily do this. It's been part of my daily routine, like brushing teeth and taking a shower. The only solution for you, I M H O, might be a professional to talk to. And maybe a full body check - bumps all over your head might be indicating something else .....
tonymia 8 Jun 2009
you have got to admit thought hat you are VERY biased and BLINDED by your own negative expereince...There are many who have had good esults are and are very happy..go read alll the hairtransplant forums WITH befor ean dafter photos..and yes on these sites EVERYONE is away of the tricks many use to show better results..eg. lighting. I think like ANY surgery..most will benefit and be satisfied although not 100% and there will aalways be a smalle rminority like you who are fully unsatisifed. i think if you get FUE and use it sparingly and in responsibliy you will be fine...I mean look..I got a nose job and fully one third on this website do not recommend this porcedure..why??? I was happy, I recommend it..it is not perfect..it is even less than I expected..but I did my research made sure my doctor didnt do too much and so i got what I asked for and am fine with it..it looks better than before...yeat again you can read on this site the horror stories of thowse who have had to go in for 3-4 surgeries.. if your hair is so damaged then shave kit and get a toupee or get a job wheree you can wear a hat..work from home ect...your story is imprtant to tell but you cannot say al hairtransplants are a nightmare ect..you are wrong..I haveseen photos that look pretty good..
Understand 12 Jun 2009
I'll tell you what it's very simple (the truth usually is) just go to yahoo's homepage www.yahoo.com and type in "hair transplant repair" in quotation marks. What you will find is that 335,000 (yes thousand) hits come up. Look at pictures and read peoples stories of how these procudures have ruined their lives and then come back and tell me how in your expert opinion,[never having the procedure done and not working in the hair transplant industry] that I am in the minority. The truth will always overcome in the end...........I just don't want anyone else to suffer in the mean time.
noesis 3 Aug 2009
I can undestand if you feel you need to vent, but when you cross the line into inaccurate facts, you do a disservice to many people. Actually, venting can enrage you and prolong self-misery. I Yahooed "hair transplant repair" and yes I saw poor results, but most of those results came from outdated and/or undated procedures all around the world since the beginning of hair transplant time. Close to 811,000 procedures around the world take place last year alone which gives a more accurate perspective compared to your unanalyzed and undated "335,000" figure for ALL years. BTW "good hair transplants" draws millions of hits but that's unanalyzed and undated like your information. It's understood by that hair transplant has evolved from its early and scarring, which is inevitable with any incision, is tremendously minimized in both the donor and recipient areas. I met a guy who still wears a buzz cut after a transplant and his scar isn't noticable! You insist on calling your surgeon a "top doctor", but your entire thread indicates otherwise? Do you think that all the rest of us are too obtuse to not discern unreliable surgeons and their misleading information or pictures. It's certainly unfortunate that you've had such a bad experience, but you shouldn't project it onto everyone else.
Understand 16 Aug 2009
Ok where do I start. First off when you put "good hair transplants" in quotation marks on www.yahoo.com only 163 hits come up. You said millions. Just a little gap don't you think? Like I said a lot of these people obviously work in this industry I'm trying to warn you about. Buyer Beware.
noesis 17 Aug 2009
I didn't put the terms in as a quote. However, when I do using Google I get 459,000 hits for "good hair transplants". I notice that you don't attempt quantify how many "so many lives" are "ruined". Even if you came up with 100 examples, it would account for maybe .0001% of the hair transplants in a year. But aside from this pettifogging, the larger issues remain. Yes, you will be left with a scar. In fact, ANY cut leaves a scar. Granted the scar from a strip procedure isn't comparable to the nick from a shaving cut, but anyone who goes with the strip donor procedure knows this and accepts that he'll probably never wear a buzz cut again. You categorically deny any "new and improved procedures", but the trichophytic closure technique makes the scar virtually undetectable. Since you're closed to the idea that any pictures of results are less than a deception, you would probably never believe that. I too have misgivings about the FUE procedure but I don't address ALL hair restorations procedures categorically as ALL the same by all doctors. It's like saying that an open cholecystectomy or laparoscopic cholecystectomy to remove a gall bladder are the same and regardless of the surgeons? You're comparing apples with oranges. Your doctor must have used a puncher greater than 1.2mm for the scarring in the recipient area that you describe. I'm not sure about your criteria for a "top doctor in the country", but I'm sure you'd agree that the guy(s) you picked really weren't. You categorically deny any "new and improved procedures", but the trichophytic closure technique makes the scar virtually undetectable. Since you're closed to the idea that any pictures of results are less than a deception you would never believe that. Like you I too have misgivings about the FUE procedure, but I don't address ALL hair restorations procedures categorically as ALL the same. It's like saying that an open cholecystectomy or laparoscopic cholecystectomy to remove a gall bladder are the same and regardless of the surgeons? You're comparing apples with oranges. BTW, you might want to check out the negative comments about the fraxel procedure including 45% of the negative critiques on realself.
geminidb8 (unregistered guest) 19 Aug 2009
Most results are fair to poor. I have been going through this since 1986, worked in the hair replacement industry and have seen more bad than good. If the results were so good then why then are there not clinics offering to repair the vice presidents hair transplants? If this industry were so great then why even advertise? There would be no bald people if it were so great. The best results are very very rare. The clinics choose the best photos and you the public never see the many, many bad ones. Elton John is wearing a wig to cover his and he has more money than most people reading this forum. If they were so great why then does no doctor correct him? The industry is corrupt and has ruined more lives than it has helped. Much of the truth is very hidden and the clinics do not want you to know the whole very sad picture. Truth kills sales.
Understand 22 Aug 2009
OK again put "good hair transplants" in quotation marks in www.google.com and 460,000 hits with THOSE WORDS come up. HOWEVER, check the actual websites and there are a total of 33, including your post by the way. Yes, a lot of people are not satisfied with fraxel. So they wasted some money and were red for a few months. With a hair transplant you are seriously scarred for life both from the donor scar and the thousands of implanted hairs. If I was allowed by site rules I would post websites with countless thousands of angry scarred patients who's lives have been ruined. But I will let people do their own research through the hundreds of thousands of websites on their own under "hair transplant repair" on yahoo and/or google. They can also look through the 33 websites for "good hair transplants" which are by the way almost entirely sponsored by the hair transplant industry that you so honorably represent.
Ankur 2 Nov 2009
hooo.... i am totally scared of transplant now.
ohhhkaayyy 22 Dec 2009
Post pictures of your "horrible" hair transplant if you want to warn the world
Tom at RealSelf (Community Manager) 26 Dec 2009

For what it's worth, regardless of search results in Google or Yahoo, there is considerable demand for hair replacement.

We did a National survey with Harris Interactive. If money was no issue, 20% of men (and 5% of women) would get hair transplants.

Clearly not lost on anyone in this discussion, hair replacement is a major procedure that requires extensive research.  So, I encourage more of you who've undergone it to share it anonymously. 

Here is the form for briefly describing the pros and cons: hair replacement review form

Thanks for posting on RealSelf.com!

Tom, Founder of RealSelf

FreDraken 19 Jul 2010
I had a procedure in Los Angeles in Feb 2009. 2300 follicular units for $8,000. I am super pleased with the results. It was no more painful than a dental cleaning. I see otherwise great-looking men who are driving nice cars and walking around with noticeable hair loss and think, "jeez, I know this guy can afford to have his hair fixed, so what IS the problem?" I guess either he's afraid of being considered a little bit vain or it just hasn't occurred to him. As far as VANITY goes, look, if you lost one of your front teeth to a raging abscess, would you walk around with a big hole in your smile or would you have an implant so it disappeared as an issue? Of course. GOOD hair replacement is fairly recent and it's not exactly cheap yet, but a hair transplant will make you look a heck of a lot better; perhaps 10 years younger, and will last the rest of your life.
bmark 30 Sep 2010
FreDraken could you please share the name of your doctor?
Tom at RealSelf (Community Manager) 29 Oct 2010

Would you be willing to post a review?  This unhappy hair transplant review just arrived

7760anon 1 Nov 2010
Finasteride seems to have solved my problem, and I am not going for the plugs....

I am buyingn the 5mg, which cost me about EUR10 per month, and then cut them in four with the Swiss Steel pill cutter. I admit, one day it might be a little more than 1mg, and next day a little less. But it seems to work perfectly, and for EUR 2,50 per MONTH .......
Tom at RealSelf (Community Manager) 1 Nov 2010

7760anon - my only concern is the recent study about Finasteride.

From Drug Watch:

According to results from a recent analysis published in the Archives of Dermatology, popular baldness drug finasteride (Propecia) may cause some patients to experience erectile dysfunction.

The analysis examined results from 12 studies that included 3,927 men. Results found that although most men experienced an increase in hair count while taking the medication, approximately one in 80 men experienced erectile dysfunction.

According to study author Dr. Jose Manuel Mella, the side effect isn't likely to deter men from taking the drug.

"It seems that most men taking this drug really prefer to have hair," Dr. Mella said.

Dr. Mella and his team note that the data collected from the studies is of "moderate quality." He explains that the results may have been impacted by outside factors, but adds that the data is reliable overall.

7760anon 7 Nov 2010
I prefer to have less sex, than less hair.
Numerous other medication MAY influence the need for sex.
7760anon 17 Mar 2011
So do I ;-)

Post a Comment

used for verification

Read more Hair Transplant reviews