Is It Worth It? --PS Gave Me a Morph, but I'm Not Sure It's Worth the Money - Chicago, IL

Hi guys, I could really use some honest (but...

Hi guys, I could really use some honest (but hopefully gentle) opinions about a morph my PS created for me. The picture shows what my doctor said was possible for my nose. (I have a bulbous tip and medium-thick skin).

To me --the person who wakes up and falls asleep with this nose-- it's a big difference. --Especially the front view. The side view looks almost exactly the same to me.

But I've shown the morph to some close family members, and they said you could not really tell, and I was disappointed. Now, I don't know what to think....

What do you think? Is there a difference? Is it worth the big pay check?

I don't want there to be such a huge difference with my rhinoplasty, but I also want there to be a definite improvement. From what I've been researching many people who get rhinoplasties confess, post-surgery, that no one seemed to even notice a difference.

It just seems like an awful lot of money, pain and inconvenience if nobody even notices an improvement, doesn't it?

Thank you for you help!

Thank you! Keep em' coming!

Thank you guys! I guess I should have explained some stuff better. I do want a nose job because of how I feel about it.... (boring details omitted). But the part where I'm uncertain is if it makes a difference or not from someone else's perspective. I like his morph a lot, and he said for the purposes of making sure this baby works and looks good for many years down the road that this was the most reliable, long-term option --which is what I want. I don't want multiple nose jobs if I can help it!

When my close family members didn't seem to think it was much a difference, I was a little unsure because I want there to be one (for the better). But it sounds like it's still pretty much 50/50. The choice comes down to me, which I'm okay with, but I know a lot of folks on this site come at this with some very intelligent, experienced perspectives...which I could use!!

I'm a little unsure that I didn't come to my doc with some more of my own ideas about my nose. He did the morph, and I liked it and that was pretty much that....Now, I think I should have maybe brought some pictures to show him more what I was thinking. But I didn't just want some Hollywood actress's nose on my face... Well maybe I do...but that's necessarily an option. I've heard that thick/medium skin can be an issue with shrinking...it doesn't seem to want to fit the new shape of the nose, so some doc's (perhaps most) try to be conservative to prevent some bad results.

Anywho, do you guys have ideas of some nose types that may work good with my features? In case I schedule another consult for a second opinion, I think I'll bring some ammo this time! :)

On a scale from 1 to 10, how big is the difference to you?

Done. and Done. Thank you, thank you to anyone who makes it to the bottom of this thread!! (You, I mean you, are personally awesome!)

Thank you!! Great Advice!

First of all, thank you! Thank you! for all your comments. Everyone has been so smart and supportive in their comments, and I really appreciate it!

I've got a lot to chew on. I'm definitely going to give this a lot more thought before I jump into it. I know I'm not happy with my current nose, but do I hate it? Nope. I'm thankful to have a nose that works okay (except for a little block in the left side that doesn't really affect my breathing much). And many of you are right, so much can go wrong, and will it really change how I feel about my face? Maybe, maybe not. Until I'm certain, I'm not going to go under the knife!

Second, a lot of you have given me some great advice about my surgeon and my morphs. I realize now that I went into my first consult way under-prepared. I have so many unanswered questions now, and I'm going to talk to my doctor's surgical RN this week to clear some of them up.

Here's some of the stuff I want to get answered:

1. For the image I was given, is that a 1-year estimate? 6-month estimate? What?
2. I read that alar batten grafts can temporarily increase the width and hardness of the nose? Is the case? Why is my doctor using them?
3. What will my nose feel like? Will it be soft and natural-feeling? Or will it be harder than I am used to? Will I have a problem blowing my nose (Sorry! But I got to ask!) What kind of short-term and long-term changes can I expect?
4. Are there any unforeseen side-effects/ risks that I should be aware of before I commit to surgery?
5. I read that spreader grafts are to reinforce the bridge of the nose to prevent collapse. My Doc. said I would not need much changed with my bridge. Perhaps a little smoothing out. I'm worried about the spreader graft because I heard it can increase the width of the tip? Is that the case?
6. Where are the grafts coming from? --Ear? Rib?
7. In what situation does he use Rib? This is a primary rhinoplasty, and I've heard some mixed input about the necessity of extensive reconstruction with rib cartilage on a primary/ low-to-moderate rhinoplasty.
8. How much is my doc. intending to "reconstruct"? Is this a simple, easy sort of fix? Or does he think it is a more challenging situation (for reasons I don't know) that will involve more extensive revision and/or grafting?
9. --I'm really worried about grafts! As you can probably tell (:
I don't know what to expect with them, and I've heard a lot people on the internet who complain about how awful grafts can be. What do I need to know and what should I expect?
10. How many grafts will I get? How will it feel? Will my nose be able to bend and move? What will my skin feel like? Will it be stretched?
11. What kind of pain medication does my doc. usually prescribe post-treatment?
12. How often does he like to do follow-ups?
13. Where in the nose does he intend to place grafts ?

Okay, that's it!! Is that a lot? Too much detail maybe? I don't know, but until I feel better about the answers to these questions and know exactly what I'm signing up for....I think I'm going to put off surgery.

If you have any of the answers to these questions, especially experience with grafts, please post! I'm sure it'd be a use to me and to people like me in the same situation.

Also, as a little follow-up, the reason that I'm asking so much about grafts is that in the poor reviews of my doctor, I've heard he can seem to go a little overboard on the grafting....Now, I'm not a doctor, and for many of these people I do not know what kind of situation they are in with their nose, so it may all be justified...but it may not, and I just want to know more about what's in my doc's head before surgery so I'm better prepared.

Also, many of you gave me some great advice about researching my doc. Something I didn't do before my consult was check my state board of medical licensing to see whether my doc had any malpractice or disciplinary action against him. This is a simple step but it made me feel better doing it. Also, as I understand it, some docs relocate to another state when they've had a malpractice claim so that they have a clean record in a new state. So if a doc has practiced in multiple states, you have to check each one.....

I'm not sure if this is the best way to research my doc. I would really like to know if anyone has a more efficient or more accurate method of research--?

Thank you again! I hope you're all off to a good week!

New Morph!

Hey guys, taking the advice of many of you, I saw another doctor and he gave me a new morph....Now, I know what you guys are probably going to say: There's no difference! And I would agree with you, but I think that's my own darn fault. I kind of freak out when the doctor just started going to town and showing me his idea of how to do my nose. The nose looked chopped off! ...and I think I might have said that....and scared him into showing me a more conservative approach. I like conservative. Conservative is good in my opinion, but I'm not thrilled with this morph either. I just don't know how to tell a doc what I'm thinking...maybe that's because I don't really know what I'm thinking? Ha!

Anyways, here it is. Tell me what you think. I'd love to know how you guys talked to your docs. I feel like this is such a big decision ---it's changing your nose!--but I don't really know how to communicate what I want. I took so much time talking to my doc. (he really was great in answering all of my technical questions) but I kind of lost time on the morph because I just left it with what he showed me..... Oh dear. I really liked him and felt comfortable with him. And I do feel like he listened to what I said, but I would like this morph to be changed a bit....I feel that the tip is still a little too bulbous for the kind of change I want. But when I say that, doctors seem to interpret that I want the nose to point up. But I would really rather it be flat...

I wonder if it would help if I sent my docs some pics....Have any of you ever done that after the consult? My doc said I could email him and communicate with him. I think I should take him up on it.
Was this review helpful? 1 other found this helpful

Comments (40)

Sort by

I think you look great in the before shots. Your nose is very pretty. Save your money for when you get older. :)
  • Reply
In my opinion you can see a difference in the front view but not as much in the side view. To me your side view looks great to begin with. When I went to my plastic surgeon I had a list of questions. Don't be afraid to ask a lot of questions. With the morph I would say if pics can help you communicate I would bring them, but let the surgeon know what it is that you like about the pics. When it comes to people noticing I know it's natural to want people to see a difference but in my experience people really don't notice. I had a few people say to me that I looked good but asides from people I told(even some of them forgot) others haven't noticed. A lot of times people aren't paying as much attention to things that we don't like about ourselves. I know that you had mentioned that you won't have the procedure until you are completely sure and that is a good thing. You want to feel completely confident in your choice.
  • Reply
Guess what!,, yes I did bring with me a morph of me that I printed for him of the perfect nose I want to an appointment with my surgeon and he did not take it bad, he said "yes you can have it almost like this" and at the end I said "I'd feel better if you keep the morph so you'll know what I want when the day has come" it was ok I guess , you know what I'm gonna say do you.. ---there is no difference and maybe there is nothing more to do with your already perfect nose ? lets face it :O)
  • Reply
I think there is no difference (maybe a 1)- I think your natural nose is very pretty and there is absolutely no difference in my view. Spend the money on things you enjoy, activities with family & friends that you'll treasure instead of this procedure :)
  • Reply
Thank you! That's very sweet of you. I'm definitely taking my time with this decision.
  • Reply
Hi, I think your morph looks exactly like a smaller version of the original!! Why dont you visit a couple other surgeons and try to see them? If you're not 100% happy with the morph, GO TO ANOTHER DOCTOR. You're doing job interviews, here; don't go with the first guy you saw!! I didn't like any Chicago docs, so I went to LA and it was well worth the drive!! Good luck!!!
  • Reply
Based on the way you ask the question, it sounds like you want more change than the doctor realizes
  • Reply
I really like your natural nose, it is very pretty. This nose is who you are and you may miss it once it's gone. Unless you absolutely hate it, I would leave it alone. Plastic Surgery is extremely risky and those words mean nothing until you actually experience all that can go wrong. On a scale from 1 to 10, the difference would be not much, 3? You are a natural beauty, stay that way :)
  • Reply
I agree with you Tara! I say only do your nose if you either broke it or its so terrible looking that you cannot live with it.
  • Reply
I agree. Only follow through if you hate your nose so much that you don't think surgery could possibly make it worse! My nose was horrible!
  • Reply
I agree too with Tara Anne from a guy, you are just fine the way u r , and for the money I hope the change will be significant because it is easy to morph I can do it with photoshop and it is always perfect in a morph .. imagine that ur profile becomes ugly and front view is ok ... well dont touch anything.
  • Reply
The front is a big difference. Your side view not so much but only because it looks good already. No one can tell that I had it done, not even family, so don't expect them to have a huge input.
  • Reply
I just had my rhinoplasty done three weeks ago in Chicago :) I was hesitant and almost went back for a second consultation because I felt the morph did not look different enough to justify the price. In the end, I trusted the surgeon's judgement, and I love my new nose so far. Good luck!
  • Reply
Do you mind me asking who was your doctor in Chicago? I am from here and looking for a revision doctor. Just wondering if its someone I have not seen yet.
  • Reply
Dr. Shah. This was my primary, I'm not familiar with how he is with revisions, but I'm really happy with mine!
  • Reply
Congrats on your successful surgery! I hope it only gets better with time. I don't know how it he is with revisions either as I only see and hear about his primaries.
  • Reply
I saw the comment on Dr T. There are lots of mixed reviews on him that is probably why she is suggesting to stay away.
  • Reply
Hi, I would definitely consult with other docs before you make a final decision. If they all give essentially the same morph then that should give you a little more confidence. Look for docs that specialize in Rhino, and the good ones are usually not inexpensive. I can see the changes and think it would be an improvement, but the only opinion that matters is yours! It is your face you must live with the results, be sure that exactly what you want is done. Be true to yourself and listen to your inner voice. Best of luck!!
  • Reply

I can definitely tell from the front view. The side is more subtle. Honestly, people are so generally unobservant about the nuances of other's features that of course your family doesn't notice. My boyfriend of five years at the time said he didn't notice when I got my rhinoplasty and it was a major difference (at least to me). You have to do what makes you happy.

Just make sure you choose a really good rhinoplasty surgeon. Here's what doctors say to look for.

Good luck and please let us know what you decide to do!

  • Reply
It's a subtle change but makes a huge difference! I'm gonna tell u straight up that people won't know you had your nose done if you end up lookin like this morph. People don't know why I look better and my change was more drastic than yours--my family and best friends didn't notice!!!!!! They will tell you not to do the surgery. Like someone here said, if you're doing it so you can stop thinking about your nose, I'm not sure about that. I think about it WAYYYY more now than before, but perhaps down the road I won't think about it-it's too early for me to say. I can't comment Bout price bc I am not familiar with Chicago prices And don't know what's normal there. Even if you like that doctor, always get several opinions anywy
  • Reply
Thank you! I'm okay wit people not knowing! I just didn't know if the difference was as good as I thought it was in my own little head...given my current relationship with my nose (:
  • Reply
By the way, I think you nose looks super cute!
  • Reply
Thanks :))) so happy I have a cute one! U will have a cute one too! Very swollen today from the heat :/ if you want it badly, do it
  • Reply
do it
  • Reply