Why are oral surgeons allowed to do breast reduction surgery?

In today's Seattle PI there is a story about a woman who is suing an oral surgeon for a botched breast reduction ("Oral Surgeon faces new suit").  The doctor also has a record of a cosmetic facial procedure that led to a death. How does this happen in the first place? The story says the doctor was not trained in plastic surgery.  Why isn't this against the law, or is it?

Sort: Date | Helpful
12 answers to “Why are oral surgeons allowed to do...”

A: Oral surgeon and breast reduction

Bahram Ghaderi, MD

Unfortunately there some of these incidents every year. Our society has tried over the years to educate the public as well as lawmakers to prevent non-qualified surgeons/physicians from performing procedures they were not trained in. The best thing to do is ask important questions such as: "Are you board... more

A: Good question, but not a good answer.

David A. Dreyfuss, MD

State license boards do not limit procedures to a license.  This means that anyone can call themselves a "Cosmetic Surgeon", even an oral surgeon or dentist.  You need to be educated as a consumer.  You need to seek out the most qualified doctor to take care of you specific needs... more

A: We (Plastic Surgeons) ask the same question....

Marshall T. Partington, MD

Confidence and trust are the two main requirements in choosing the right plastic surgeon. However, there is one very important factor that often gets missed when emotions are running high and the goal seems so close within reach! Many states do not have laws that protect the consumers from false or misleading... more

A: It is an outrage

Richard P. Rand, MD

There should be laws against doctors practicing surgery beyond their scope of training.  An oral surgeon has no formal training in plastic surgery of the breast.  As such, it is only ego and hubris that allows someone to think they can do this operation.  Foolishly and naively, they are taking... more

A: The laws governing medical practice vary from state to state!

Manish H. Shah, MD

The issue that you bring up is known as scope of practice. Basically the issue boils down to who is appropriately trained to perform which invasive procedures. Some states are broad in their definition enabling any physician to be licensed to practice medicine and surgery. As a consumer, I would recommend... more

A: One would think that there would be laws against this!

David Shafer, MD

This is a good question and there really is no answer. Unfortunately, almost anyone can set up shop and unknowing patients fall victim to unscrupulous doctors (and non doctors). My best advice to you is to throughly research your doctors prior to seeing them. Go to the internet, message boards, talk to... more

A: Buyer Beware! An Unqualified Surgeon Is a Kick In The Teeth!

Athleo Louis Cambre, MD

Sadly, this story is a predictable outcome of a surgical procedure being performed by an un-qualified individual, most likely in an un-licensed setting. Unfortunately, the patient in this case did not do her basic homework to check the credentials of the "surgeon", and may have been lured in by a surgical fee... more

A: Look for a doctor trained by the American Board of Plastic Surgery

Brent Moelleken, MD

In America, there are many competing forces that act to influence which laws are passed: lobbyists from organizations, restraint of trade laws, etc. The lawmakers will simply not protect you from having any surgery done by any doctor or dentist, no matter how minimal their qualifications. By the time the... more

A: Consumers need to look for ABMS board certification

Robert Singer, MD

Unfortunately there is no law in any state that restricts the scope of practice strictly to a physician's board certification.  While there are some "pedigree" laws that require physicians disclose board certification,  unfortunately few consumers understand or recognize the authenticity of... more

A: It's unfortunately a common practice

Shahram Salemy, MD

I don't think I can add much to what has already been said, other than to say it happens and it can be very difficult for patients to know the exact training and qualifications of their surgeon. In general, surgeons who are properly trained with the proper credentials are more than happy to share them with... more

More answers to Why are oral surgeons allowed to do breast reduction surgery?
New York City - It is a shame!
Santa Barbara - Sad but true- look for certification by the American Board...

Ask your question:

before & after photos

IMPORTANT: As noted in our Terms of Service, the information found on RealSelf.com, including that provided by professionals in the Questions & Answers area, is a general educational aid. The Questions and Answers contain opinions and views created by community members. RealSelf.com is not responsible for the accuracy of any information posted by community members. Do not rely on this information as a substitute for personal medical or healthcare advice, or for diagnosis or treatment purposes.