Ask a doctor

For 4th Surgery, Should I Removing an Encapsulated Saline Implant and Replace W/ 'Gummy Bear' Implant?

47 yr old, healthy with recurrent encapsulation in right breast. I am considering a 4th surgery to replace my saline, submuscular 350cc implant with a cohesive silicone, gummy bear implant. Am I wasting my time and need to just explant? which I do not want to.

Doctor Answers (6)

Explant and then later replace implants



If the encapsulation is persistent, you might consider explantation followed by an interval without implants. This frequently allows the tissues to soften allowing implant replacement later. Not everyone will go for replacement later of course.


It is a choice. :)


Best Regards,


John Di Saia MD

Orange Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 22 reviews

Recurrent capsular contracture


Recurrent capsular contracture is a difficult problem. The best regimen I have found us complete capsulectomy, implant exchange and a placement of acellular dermis like Strattice. The data is currently anecdotal but very strong. There are a number of peer reviewed articles now showing the benefits of this approach 

Web reference: Http://

Boca Raton Plastic Surgeon
4.5 out of 5 stars 23 reviews

Recurrent capsular contracture and options


Dr Sherman makes very good points below about when to say enough is enough. It is difficult for you as a patient with additional expense, recovery time and then the emotional let down with a recurrent capsular contracture.

I have personally had good experience for recurrent capsular contracture patients with the use of an acellular dermal matrix such as Strattice. This is a materiel derived from porcine (pig) skin that allows a new coverage for at the least a portion of the implant  and early studies have shown a decreased ability for the body to reform a tighter capsule. There is no replacement for an in-person consultation with exam so my recommendation would be to see a plastic surgeon with experience with experience with these products. This is an important decision so I recommend you see the new plastic surgeon with questions in hand.

I hope this helps.

Dr Edwards

Web reference:

Las Vegas Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 8 reviews

Consider implant removal and fat grafting


As the surgeons before me have indicated; after multiple recurrences of capsular contracture, you should seriously consider removal of the implants. But all is not lost, I routinely perform fat grafting on women who have had implants removed after complications, with excellent results.

Web reference:

Orlando Plastic Surgeon
4.5 out of 5 stars 29 reviews

Time to bail out


When patient comes to me at the age of 47 has had four operations on her breasts the immediate question must come into mind, "when do we stop this." Your financial and psychological investment in the previous procedures has been substantial and the change and adjustment without implants might be difficult. But it appears that you are on the train of no return, destined to repeat these surgeries. It takes an honest surgeon to tell you this, and an experienced surgeon who realizes that after four operations is very little that he or she can do. It appears that your body forms capsules around the implants, and will continue to do so.

New York Plastic Surgeon
4.5 out of 5 stars 11 reviews

Multiple capsular contractures


Some folks do not respond well to implants and their bodies repeatedly make capsular contractures.  Saline below the muscle has the lowest rate of this and silicone is higher.  So you already have had the best chance of success and it failed.  Strattice or Alloderm is getting some press about reducing capsules but this is just anectodtal at this point and not something to base your decisions on.  Maybe either leave them alone or take them out.

Seattle Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 44 reviews

These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.