Rhinoplasty Q&A
80%
WORTH IT RATING
"Worth It Rating" shows the % of consumer reviewers that stated the procedure was "Worth It" or not. See more RealSelf Worth It Ratings or Add Your Review
1,003 Reviews
Rhinoplastybefore & after photos
View Before and Afters

Average Rhinoplasty Cost: $5,975

Learn about Rhinoplasty

5,053 people and 803 doctors are talking about Rhinoplasty

Get Free Email Updates

Have Had Two Consultations, Which Surgeon Do I Choose for my Rhinoplasty Proceedure?

asked 6 months ago by christylv in PA
Latest answer by Richard W. Fleming, MD
Question viewed 312 times
Tags: choosing a surgeon, consultation

i just had two consults from two different surgeons this month. I am so confused because i got two totally different opinion's. The first surgeon said i was wide in my bridge and needed a full rhino. the second surgeon said i was narrow in my bridge and he would just file that tiny bump i have. i really dont have a bump at all. i just want more definition in the tip of my nose. both said they can do that. the second surgeon talked about grafting and seemed to do more tip work. Who should i do?

15 answers to Have Had Two Consultations, Which Surgeon Do I Choose for my Rhinoplasty Proceedure?

+1

Different Recommendations, Same Nose

As you've seen, it is possible to get very different recommendations during consultations for rhinoplasty. You have several choices to resolve the issue: You can get another consultation, you can ask these surgeons to show you pictures of patients that had similar problems before surgery, you can ask to meet with other patients that had a nose like yours prior to their operation. You can submit pictures here which can be reviewed by participating surgeons. Go to my website for... more
Richard W. Fleming, MD

Beverly Hills Facial Plastic Surgeon
+1

Have Had Two Consultations, Which Surgeon Do I Choose for my Rhinoplasty Proceedure?

Seek a third or fourth opinion. Also follow up consults with the first 2 is helpful to compare. There is no wrong answer but you need to fully understand the operation. {Posting photos could help us give an idea of what we might do.
Darryl J. Blinski, MD

Miami Plastic Surgeon
+1

Two Consultations with Two opinions; Which Surgeon Do I Choose for my Rhinoplasty Proceedure

It would have been helpful if you posted several views of your nose for us to advise you accordingly. Without any objective data, no one can advise if you do or do not have a wide nose etc. I would advise you to see at least another Plastic surgeon, take notes and go with the surgeon who fully answers your questions and with whom you felt the most comfortable. Good Luck. Peter a Aldea, MD
Peter A. Aldea, MD

Memphis Plastic Surgeon
+1

Choosing a rhinoplasty surgeon

Which surgeon listened to you? Which surgeon suggested a result in line with what you are looking for? Which one made the most sense?
Daniel Greenwald, MD

Tampa Plastic Surgeon

bayshoreplasticsurgery.com

+1

Rhinoplasty

If you see 10 surgeons you will get 10 different opinions. Despite that some of these surgeons will get comparable results doing slightly different procedures. The best way for you to use this online forum is submit photos and see if the online surgeons agree more with one of the surgeons you saw than the other. My response to your question/post does not represent formal medical advice or constitute a doctor patient relationship. You need to consult with i.e. personally see a board... more
Aaron Stone, MD

Los Angeles Plastic Surgeon
+1

Differing surgeon opinions

Christy, Surgeons are sometimes very opinionated individuals. And , just as in life, surgical opinions can vary widely. I would recommend a third opinion. It is likely that the third surgeon will agree with one of the two other surgeons. Then, let the majority rule. Good luck!
Kenneth R. Francis, MD

Manhattan Plastic Surgeon
+1

Best Way to Choose Your Rhinoplasty Surgeon

Hi Christylv, In cases such as yours, where patients cannot choose which surgeon to have their rhinoplasty with, I recommend flipping a coin. Just kiddin'. The most important aspect of rhinoplasty from a patient's perspective is choosing their surgeon most carefully (see web reference below). It would be most helpful if you included photos of your nose along with what bothers you about your nose. You may wish to get another opinion. Whoever you choose,... more
Michael A. Persky, MD

Los Angeles Facial Plastic Surgeon
+1

Who should do my rhinoplasty?

Go back for second consultations to get a better impression. Look at before and after results from each surgeon. Make a judgment. Go with your gut.
Steve Laverson, MD

San Diego Plastic Surgeon

feelbeautiful.com

+1

Nose job

The surgeon who is board certified by the american board of plastic surgery, and has done at least a hundred nose jobs. I know this sounds simplistic but surgeries carry risks and results vary. The surgeon who can fix any problem that may occur is better (in my mind) than the one who can simply do the surgery.
Ayman Hakki, MD

Washington Plastic Surgeon
+1

Choose the surgeon who listens to your concerns

I would suggest choosing the surgeon who listens to your concerns. Look at lots of before and after pictures to see if you like the quality of their work. Be careful with computer imaging ("morphing"). You can do almost anything to your picture on a computer. Actually delivering quality results is a different matter. If you are still unsure, go seek a consultation with another surgeon. Warmest regards. Dr. Pippin
Gregory Pippin, MD

New Orleans Facial Plastic Surgeon

www.pippinmd.com

+1

Rhinoplasy Question

It is very difficult to give any solid answers since I cannot see you. However, it is very common for surgeons to have different opinions. This is based on each surgeon’s technique, background and aesthetic eye. I would have a few more consultations with doctors. This will allow you to compare and see a broad range of expert answers and suggestions. It is then up to you to choose the one that you feel most comfortable with. Best of luck to you!
Philip Young, MD

Bellevue Facial Plastic Surgeon
+1

Have Had Two Consultations, Which Surgeon Do I Choose for my Rhinoplasty Proceedure?

Did either surgeon provide computer imaging to communicate what they had in mind for the goal of the surgery? I find this helps quite a bit to match my aesthetic analysis with that of the patient. At the end of the day, you should go with the surgeon that understands what you don't like about your nose and has a reasonable plan to accomplish the changes.
Matthew Bridges, MD

Richmond Facial Plastic Surgeon

www.matthewbridgesmd.com

+1

Have Had Two Consultations, Which Surgeon Do I Choose for my Rhinoplasty Proceedure?

Without photos, of your nose...can't tell you. My advice is to find and choose your Rhinoplasty Surgeon based on their understanding and ability to follow the proper aesthetics of facial beauty. Only then, IMHO will natural beauty be achieved.
Francis R. Palmer, III, MD

Beverly Hills Facial Plastic Surgeon
+1

Rhinoplasty

Without an exam, I can not be sure what to suggest. Yes, surgeons will often give different opinions based upon their own aesthetic eye.
Steven Wallach, MD

Manhattan Plastic Surgeon
+1

Choosing Surgeon after Rhinoplasty Consultation

Rhinoplasty is not one operation, but rather many potential operations. Each person has unique anatomy and personal goals. Lastly, there are many methods or techniques to achieve your desired nose. As a result of this variability, plastic surgeons will generally differ in their professional opinion to some degree. Most patients typically require more than one visit or consultation before choosing their plastic surgeon. Consider revisiting each surgeon and continue to ask more questions. Best... more
Houtan Chaboki, MD

Washington DC Facial Plastic Surgeon

Ask a question