Stretch Eyelid Skin Possible After an Aggressive Surgery?

Dear Goldilock
Unfortunately it is very hard to unstir the cream out of the coffee.
Whereas there are a lot of great options for helping aesthetically improve the lower eyelid that has been damaged by prior lower eyelid cosmetic surgery, the options for the upper eyelid are much less palatable and satisfactory.
The frame issue that Dr. Seify is referring to is over resection of upper eyelid fat in the central fat pocket exposing the groove created by the reflection of tendon complex of the superior oblique muscle.
That is not the problem you are describing. What you are talking about is that someone removed your upper eyelid fold robbing you of an very important facial feature.
Restoring the upper eyelid fold is an impossible task. Nothing will bring back the natural gentle fold that is a very important feature of the face that is removed by an aggressive upper blepharoplasty.
A skin graft does help with eyelid closure when this had been compromised by too much skin removal with the eyelid surgery. However, this is simply to achieve the ability for the eyes to close. It is not helpful in restoring the aesthetic upper eyelid fold.
Fat transfer or filling with Restylane can also soften the appearance of the sub-brow area but this is not the same thing as storing the upper eyelid fold.
I encourage you to find a surgeon who deals with post-blepharoplasty issues and have a personal consultation.
Dr. Steinsapir

Removal of excess fat in the upper lid leads to a condition called "A frame deformity" this creates a very skeletonized look. the best treatment is reconstruction with fat grafting.Removal of skin from the upper lid could be a difficult problem. Skin grafting is an asnwer but will not yield a good cosmetic result. If there is no corneal irritation and the eye closure is not affected, I would recommend to do the fat grafting first. Best of luck!