Smartlipo vs Ultrashape: Which is Best?

asked 4 years ago by anon
Latest answer by William Ting, MD
Question viewed 7,436 times
Tags: comparison

Can I get better or equal results for fat removal using ultra shape vs. smartlipo treatment?

6 answers to Smartlipo vs Ultrashape: Which is Best?

Comparing SmartLipo vs. Ultrashape or Liposonix

We are not comparing apple to apple. Smartlipo is laser-assisted tumescent liposuction that delivers consistent fat reduction vs. noninvasive ultrasonic devices such as Ultra Shape, Liposonix that attempt to emulsify fat pads but with subtle clinical benefits that may not be consistent.

William Ting, MD
Bay Area Dermatologic Surgeon

Smartlipo and Ultrashape are different concepts

Smartlipo is one of several techniques we use for liposuctioning away the fat. It has the advantage of producing significant skin tightening (as long as the area involved is not too large), besides removing the fatty deposits. We see good skin tightening, for example in the neck, and arms. It is a surgery, usually done with tumescent ( a variant of local) anesthesia. Ultrashape is not a surgery. There is no removal of fat. The theory apparently is that ultrasonic... more

Christopher J. Peers, MD
South Bend Facial Plastic Surgeon

www.peerscosmetic.com

Smartlipo is more effective than Ultrashape

Smartlipo is more effective than Ultrashape but it is an unfair comparison. Ultrashape is non-invasive and Smartlipo is a surgical procedure. There are other non-surgical fat reduction treatments, like Zerona, that would be a more similar comparison to Ultrashape., however, Ultrashape isn't approved in the United States yet.

Daryl K. Hoffman, MD
Los Gatos Plastic Surgeon

www.dkhoffmanmd.com

SmartLipo vs Ultrashape

SmartLipo is different than Ultrashape. SmartLipo is a laser liposuction treatment. Ultrashape is based on ultrasonic technology. One works on removing fat by melting the fat; the other works on lessening fat by emulsifying the fat. In the United States, the SmartLipo is an FDA-approved device, but the Ultrashape device is not yet approved. We were involved in the FDA studies on the Ultrashape and liked the way it works, but it is not yet commercially available in the United States at this... more

David Goldberg, MD
New York Dermatologic Surgeon

Smartlipo vs Ultrashape

How about neither?? Smartlipo has never been shown (including at a recent national plastic surgery meeting) to be better than traditional liposuction. Ultrashape will only give you a minimal result at best. Why not go the a Board Certified plastic surgeon and ask them what is best for you and what will really give you a result you are happy with?

Richard P. Rand, MD, FACS
Seattle Plastic Surgeon

Smartlipo versus Ultrashape

Ultrashape is a non-invasive treatment which claims to destroy fat cells. I have not used it, but looking at their before and after pictures on their company website, I would have to say that these would not be acceptable results unless you are looking for minimal change on targeted ares. Smartlipo uses a laser to destroy the fat cells. I then use a very small traditional liposuction cannula to suck out the melted fat. Smartlipo is also good for targeted areas but not indicated for... more

David Shafer, MD
New York Plastic Surgeon

www.ShaferPlasticSurgery.com

Ask a question

Get Free Email Updates