Should I have my rhinoplasty done by a facial plastic surgeon or a general plastic surgeon?
Answers (4)
I think that either one can do it well or poorly. It really depends upon their experience and their artistic eye. The best way to find the right one for you is to talk to friends that have had good results, and good experiences.
A facial plastic surgeon’s knowledge and skill comes from exclusively treating medical and surgical conditions pertaining to ears, nose and throat (ENT) prior to facial cosmetic surgery training. This extensive background in ENT equips a facial plastic surgeon to address any breathing, reconstructive or cosmetic issues regarding the nose. Dr. Portuese has performed thousands of successful nasal surgeries including cosmetic, reconstructive, sinus related, breathing issues or a broken nose.
Have it done by a good surgeon who performs rhinoplasty regularly
I couldn't agree more with Dr. Litner's comments.
Rhinoplasty is an art, a passion, an obsession. Those surgeons (regardless of whether a facial plastic surgeon or a plastic surgeon) who will dedicate their time and effort to rhinoplasty will inevitably become better at it.
Qualified rhinoplasty surgeons
There are a few types of surgeons who are qualified to do rhinoplasty.
Facial Plastic Surgeons like us limit their cosmetic and reconstructive surgery practices to facial work while General Plastic Surgeons may do work on the face and the rest of the body. While both types of surgeons frequently do rhinoplasty, recent statistics suggest that Facial Plastic Surgeons, despite being far out-numbered, are now doing more rhinoplasties in America than their General Plastic surgical colleagues.
The main difference between the two types of Plastic Surgeons is how they are trained and how they arrive at doing what they do.
- Facial Plastic Surgeons have usually first completed residency training in Head and Neck Surgery (also known as ENT or Otolaryngology) where a large concentration of their training is in Plastic Surgery of the Face and Neck. They will then usually have gone on to further complete a dedicated Fellowship in Facial Plastic Surgery.
- General Plastic Surgeons, on the other hand, complete some 3-5 years of training in General Surgery, then a 2 year residency in General Plastic Surgery, perhaps followed by Fellowship.
So, is either more qualified to do rhinoplasty? There is nothing that gives either group dominion over a particular procedure and you shouldn’t listen to anyone who says so. There are representatives from both groups who are among the best rhinoplasty surgeons in the world. And each group also has its share of less experienced rhinoplasty surgeons.
It is true that Facial Plastic Surgeons spend much more time working on and in the nose during their training, and often in practice. And, because of their ENT backgrounds, Facial Plastic Surgeons may be, in general, more comfortable with procedures inside the nose, and especially with those rhinoplasties involving changes that affect nasal breathing (known as Functional Rhinoplasty).
Ultimately, your choice of a good rhinoplasty surgeon should come down to other more important factors, such as personal experience with rhinoplasty. You can look at other answers to rhinoplasty questions on this forum to get an idea of what to look for.



Write a comment