Fast facts

Rhinoplasty


What it is: A plastic surgery procedure to improve the appearance, proportions and structural functionality of the nose.  Rhinoplasty, commonly called a nose job, can enhance facial symmetry and harmony to improve the patient's self-confidence.  Breathing can also be improved as a result.


What it addresses: Specific aspects of the nose, such as:

- Nose size
- Nose width
- Asymmetry
- Nostrils


MORE INFORMATION

Question

Rhinoplasty - why do some surgeons seem to do the same nose for everyone?

A friend of mine said that I should avoid a certain local surgeon for my rhinoplasty because he uses a very cookie-cutter approach to rhinoplasty surgery so everyone's noses look the same afterward.  Why does this happen?


Asked by: Anonymous

Answers (5)

Sort by: Most recent | Most helpful
1
June 21, 2008
Steven Wallach, MD
Steven Wallach, MD
Board Certified
Plastic Surgeon

I remember growing up with similar memories. There were surgeons in my  area that did very "cookie cutter" type procedures.  Everyone had an over-resected looking button nose. Unfortunately, this often left the person as a "nasal cripple" in terms of function. That is to say, they could not breathe.  

My goal is to provide a patient with a natural aesthetically-pleasing looking nose but as importantly maintain excellent function.  And, I would like to think that the majority of my colleagues want the same.  I don't know why some may still perform the cookie cutter approach, but it is like a shoe maker, not everyone wears the same size or style shoe, and you have to accomodate and change your ways to provide the best possible result for very different situations.

2
June 20, 2008
William A. Portuese, MD
William A. Portuese, MD
Board Certified
Facial Plastic Surgeon

There is no one perfect nose which works for everyone.  Modern Rhinoplasty techniques are all quite different so that each Rhinoplasty surgery is tailored to fit the patient’s unique facial features.  Many years ago there were not as many techniques available to surgeons, so that many noses did look the same.

3
April 29, 2008

Everyone wants the same nose - Can you say "cutesy" nose?

Michael A. Persky, MD
Michael A. Persky, MD
Board Certified
Facial Plastic Surgeon

Some rhinoplasty surgeons have made great careers (and lots of money) out of a particular looking nose. Years ago, having a rhinoplasty was a "status" symbol. In the early years of rhinoplasty, patients and their surgeons actually wanted the nose to look "done".

When "all the noses look the same afterward" there is an obvious "done" look to the nose. The technique used is usually the same without regard for the individuality of the nose with relation to the other facial features. The local surgeon who you speak about above has patients who notice his/her "done nose job" and want that look.

In my opinion, today's beautiful nose gets out of the way of the other facial features so that the focus of attention is drawn towards the eyes. Ideally, one should not be able to tell that someone has had a rhinoplasty; it should look natural and fit the individual face. This requires making a diagnosis of what is distracting about the nose, creating a unique surgical plan, and carrying it out.

I agree with your friend that I would stay away from the cookie-cutter rhinoplasty surgeon, unless you like that "done" look.

4
April 19, 2008

Tips for selecting your rhinoplasty surgeon

Richard W. Westreich, MD
Richard W. Westreich, MD
Board Certified
Facial Plastic Surgeon

The information your friend gave you about the local surgeon can either be a positive or a negative review, depending on your perspective.

Rhinoplasty is one of the most challenging operations in plastic surgery. Everyone's nose is structurally different and there are certain apects of healing that can not be controlled by the operation itself. Short and long term outcomes in the same patient can be different, depending on how healing progresses, what the original nose looked like, and what was done to change it.

Every plastic surgeon is guided by their own personal sense of aesthetics, the specific techniques they like to use, the desires of their patients, and current trends within the field of plastic surgery and fashion. Plastic surgeons also strive for consistency in their results, so they can provide patients with accurate projections of their outcome. This can sometimes result in a surgeon having a certain look to their noses if they tend to use the same techniques over and over again. This repeated use of similar techniques is often a reflection of a surgeon's confidence in achieving a particular outcome, rather than a lack of experience or creativity.

While plastic surgery is becoming more individualized and natural appearing, it is still critically important to provide patients with consistent outcomes and realistic results. That is likely why your local surgeon produces similar noses: he or she has a particular technique that they feel very confident in using.

With all that in mind, the most important question is this: Do you like the noses that this surgeon is creating? If the answer is yes, then schedule a consultation and ask to see before and after photos. Try to see if the other patients appear to have problems that are similar to yours. If a similar nose is not obvious, then ask the surgeon to show you someone that represents your likely outcome.

  • If the surgeon does computer imaging, then have that done and see if the projection is similar to your aesthetic goal.
  • Then ask if he or she will show you other patient's computer imaging and outcomes to see if they are closely matched.

If you don't like the nose that this surgeon is producing, then find another surgeon. Either ask around or look on line for the names of other physicians. There are many before and after photos on the web, which will demonstrate to you the wide variety of outcomes that are possible.

Many surgeons, like myself, take an individualized approach to rhinoplasty. This philosophy should be reflected in their website and in the office consultation. Doing all of this research will help to educate you about the procedure, refine your goals, and help in achieving the result you desire.

5
April 9, 2008

Rhinoplasty technique or aesthetic standards could be the cause

Jason Litner, MD
Jason Litner, MD
Board Certified
Facial Plastic Surgeon

That’s a good question that doesn’t have a very good answer. Some surgeons in certain geographic areas will tend to attract a more homogeneous group of patients with similar features who may desire similar types of results. But, in a multiethnic large city, you shouldn’t be able to pass someone on the street and say to yourself, “Hey, that’s a Dr. So and So nose.”

Ideally, you shouldn’t recognize a good rhinoplasty result at all. The most common cause for this finding is that many surgeons train in and are comfortable with specific rhinoplasty techniques. As a result, they may not vary their technique substantially from patient to patient. It’s not so much a formula. But, many have honed their skills within a particular zone of comfort and they feel that this skill set has worked for them in their practices.

Sometimes it’s not a surgeon’s technique but a surgeon’s aesthetic standards that are at cause. Some surgeons have very strongly felt and unwavering ideas of what constitutes an ideal nose and they may indirectly impose these on their patients.

The trouble is that there is no aesthetic nasal standard that is ideal for everyone. There are certain features that are known to be more feminizing or that are thought to be more attractive even across racial and ethnic boundaries. And, your surgeon should guide you with respect to these when you jointly create your surgical plan. But, apart from these, your particular aesthetic should be the primary guiding factor. After all, you will have to and hopefully will be overjoyed to live with your new nose for a lifetime.

Also of critical importance is that we cannot look at your nose in isolation. An very softly attractive small feminine nose on someone else’s face may be a mismatch for your full face and strong jawline. Everyone has a slightly different aesthetic ideal when it comes to their noses. Some feel that a long, sharply defined Roman or ‘Aquiline’ nose with a straight profile is classically elegant and sophisticated. Others prefer a much softer, more natural look.

An important part of the consultative process is to help tease out your specific preferences to better inform our choices of surgical techniques. Just as there are countless aesthetic nasal ideals, there must be an equal variety of rhinoplasty techniques in which the experienced surgeon is well-versed in order to deliver the particular nose that is right for you.

Write a comment

(required, shown publicly)
(required, kept private)
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <br> <em> <strong> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <div>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may link to webpages through the weblinks registry

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
Enter the numbers in the image below (no spaces)
Image CAPTCHA

Comments for unregistered users are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Community Guidelines

Check out more Q+A about Rhinoplasty

Have a question? Ask it

IMPORTANT: As noted in our Terms of Service, the information found on RealSelf.com, including that provided by professionals in the Questions & Answers area, is a general educational aid. The Questions and Answers contain opinions and views created by community members. RealSelf.com is not responsible for the accuracy of any information posted by community members. Do not rely on this information as a substitute for personal medical or healthcare advice, or for diagnosis or treatment purposes.
  •     Cancel