I have both functional as well as cosmetic problem. I have a nose hump, spur, and breathing problem. Which surgeon is best for me to see, a plastic surgeon or an ENT surgeon?
Best Surgeon to See for Nose Hump and Breathing Problem?
Doctor Answers (6)
Board certified facial plastic surgeon
The best surgeon to perform both functional and cosmetic nasal surgery is a board-certified facial plastic surgeon. A board-certified facial plastic surgeon is also board-certified in otolaryngology, head and neck surgery. A surgeon with these qualifications is well-versed on both the internal functional component of the nose as well as the cosmetic portion of the rhinoplasty.
Agree totally with Dr Persky
With all deference to my colleague Dr. Beraka, I would love to see any hard statistics that he can produce on which specialty performs more Rhinoplasties in New York. In the United States there is absolutely no question or argument that the vast majority of Rhinoplasties and Septoplasties are performed by Facial Plastic Surgeons with primary training in Otolaryngology. That in no way however implies that one specialty is superior to another and I agree with my friend Dr Persky that the Surgeon is more important than the specialty. In the end it comes down to experience, judgement, and skill most likely in that order!
Who best to do your Rhinoplasty
You want a surgeon who specializes in Rhinoplasty. This is usually a facial plastic surgeon, and ENT specialist who specializes in plastic and reconstructive surgery of the face. However, some general plastic surgeons also specialize. The revision rate for such surgery is probably about 10% so make sure you see someone who does a lot of these procedures, no matter what the label.
You might also like...
The individual surgeon matters much more than the specialty.
Both a plastic surgeon and an ENT surgeon trained in "facial plastic surgery" can do a rhinoplasty and work on your breathing.
But of course talent and experience vary widely. Try to find someone who does a lot of noses, and look at a lot of before and after pictures. If you are unhappy at the end, it will more likely be because you don't like the way your nose looks.
In Manhattan, most noses are done by plastic surgeons.
Rhinoplasty; Best Surgeon to See for Nose Hump and Breathing Problems
Your question is very similar to a previously answered inquiry. Here is that answer:
Way to stir up the old specialty "wars".
ENT, Facial Plastic, and General Plastic Surgeons all perform septorhinoplasty. The surgical procedure is not a commodity, but an operation that combines the skill, experience, training, creativity, and aesthetic sense of beauty of the surgeon to achieve an attractive (cosmetic) as well as an excellent breathing (functional) result.
There are surgeons of all of the above cited specialities that perform the operation very well, and there are surgeons who do not. It is important to choose your rhinoplasty surgeon carefully. Ask questions, speak to previous patients, take your time.
The surgeon is more important than the speciality.
Good luck and be well.
Recommend seeing a nasal specialist
Addressing functional and cosmetic issues is important in EVERY Rhinoplasty procedure. Even in purely cosmetic cases, the functional nature should be kept in mind in order to prevent any breathing issues. It is ideal to see a surgeon who is a specialist in noses and understands both of these issues.
There are plastic surgeons who dedicate their practice to Rhinoplasty. In addition, there is a sub-specialty of ENT called Facial Plastic Surgery. A board certified facial plastic surgeon has specialized training in both plastic surgery of the face and ENT.