Restylane has become the filler of choice for the lower eye area for long lasting correction. Juvederm and Hydrelle simply have too much hyaluronic acid content and are at risk for swelling.
For patients contemplating their first injection we usually recommend Prevelle, which does not last as long but also is quite safe.
For patients who need greater and more permanent correction we steer away from semipermanent fillers in favor of LiveFill(R) often performed with an ultrshort incision cheeklift (USIC (R)).
In any event, there are many choices now that were not available a few years ago.