Natural Rhinoplasty results are what counts

Interesting observation. You have discovered one of the truths of cosmetic nasal surgery: experience counts. The operation is the most technically challenging in all the world of cosmetic surgery. Superior training, experience and an " aesthetic sense" (inherent sense of what looks right) are the hallmarks of the most accomplished cosmetic nasal surgeons.

What technique the surgeon uses should not be a criterion for doctor selection.

For all cosmetic procedures, it's only about results. Today, prospective patients are fortunate to be able to see galleries of results on cosmetic surgeons' websites. And, can scrutinize photos at the office consultation.

You are doing the right homework. Congrats!

Experience is VERY important in rhinoplasty surgery. However, the technique used does not tell you anything about experience. I have used both approaches for 30 years. Does that make me experienced? Pick the experienced surgeon whose results you like. You are smart to thoroughly explore your alternatives.