Follicular Unit Extraction or Strip for Hair Transplant?
- Asked by clichejam in karachi, pakistan
- 4 years ago
Which of the procedure is better for Hair transplant: Follicular unit extraction or strip hair transplant?
FUG vs. FUE
For over 10 years, follicular unit grafting (FUG) which is the strip procedure has been the gold standard. Over the past 3 years, follicular unit extraction (FUE) has grown in popularity, and it now constitutes around 20% of the hair procedures I perform.
FUE has one main advantage- the absence of any linear donor site scar, thus permitting the patient to shave his head if desired.
The downsides of the FUE procedure are several: typically a lower percentage of hair regrowth (for most patients an 80 to 85% rate of regrowth vs. 90plus % with FUG; higher cost; difficulty of obtaining a large number of grafts- anything more than 1500 or so requires 2 consecutive days of procedures; and the need to shave the head in the donor area.
However, FUE is still the procedure of choice for young men, men of African American ethnicity, those who have depleted their donor supplies from prior work, and those who wish to have the option of shaving the head.
Web reference: http://www.foundhair.com/pages/fue.html
FUE vs FUG
Both techniques have advantages and disadvantages. Below are the pros and cons of each:
Follicular Unit Extraction
- no linear scar on the back of the head
- almost limitless donor especially if body hair can be used
- time intensive sometimes requiring several days to complete a large case
- lower individual graft survival rate (75% vs 90%)
- cost usually 50% higher per graft
Follicular Unit Grafting
- more time efficient
- higher individual graft survival
- linear scar on the back of the head (usually not noticeable)
I don't think this is an issue of one being better or worse than the other technique, but rather a question of which technique is right for individual patient problems. I feel FUE is best suited to very young patients (teens or early 20's) with an unpredictable future pattern of hair loss, people who want to shave or cut their hair very short, and those who can't tolerate the risk of a scar. I still think FUG is the treatment of choice and the gold standard against which other techniques should be compared.
Web reference: http://www.drjohnbitner.com
FUE versus Strip grafts
Today it is getting harder and harder to find a hair transplant surgeon who does strip donor hair work. Fewer and fewer patients are willing to trade a lifelong scar for a better price. I use a mechanized system to remove the FUE grafts so as to speed the proccess somewhat. I can now make it more affordable to patients. I personally do not do strip graft work anymore because of the problems with the scar and very few requests by prospective patients.
Recent Hair Transplant Reviews
Hair Transplant Photos
FUE versus Strip for Hair Transplant?
It totally depends on the type and quality of donor hair. The most important event of a hair transplant is not how the donor hair is harvested. It is really the judgement and artistry of the doctor in inserting and designing a natural hairline. I think too much has been made about how donor hair is harvested . If a strip donor site is properly closed a scar can be minimal. If a FUE procedure is done with too many donor grafts too close together one can be left with a white visible scar.
Follicular Unit Extraction or Strip for Hair Transplant?
Both procedures produce excellent results. It basically comes down to personal preference.
The strip method has been around longer and is the most common method of hair transplantation.
The benefits are you can move more hair per procedure at a lower cost and the outcome is remarkable. The only negative I see is you are left with a linear scar in the donor site, which is typically not recognizable unless you shave your head.
Benefits of FUE's would be in the donor site. Instead of having a linear scar it would leave tiny little "dots." But again these are not visible unless you were to shave your head.
The only negatives with FUE's would be the fact that it takes longer so therefore the cost will be higher.
With the addition of Neograft however, the time factor will not be as much of a factor.
Web reference: http://www.651hair.com
Follicular Unit Extraction is possible WITHOUT a linear scar!
There is a great new technique available in a few areas of the country (including our Orlando Plastic Surgery, Skin Care, and Hair Restoration Center) called the Neograft, that allows Follicular Unit Extraction WITHOUT a linear scar on the back of your head.
We are incredibly impressed with the procedure, the easier recovery, and the outcomes. Our patients are incredibly happy.
Find a qualified doctor near you skilled in the Neograft technique. You'll be glad you did.
Web reference: http://www.DrArmandoSoto.com
FUE for shorter hair styles
If you anticipate the need to keep an overall shorter hair style, then you want to avoid the linear scar that would necesarily result from Follicular Unit Strip Surgery ( FUSS ). It would make sense to do Follicular Unit Extraction ( FUE ) instead. If you already have a strip scar from prior surgery or never anticipate keeping a short hair cut, then FUSS could be considered. I am of the opinion that FUSS is perhaps too too invasive a method for procedures involving less than 500 grafts.
Web reference: http://www.dermhairclinic.com/fue-hair-transplant/
Hair transplant option a matter of opinion
It depends on the bald area that needs coverage. It also depends on the surgeon. Concerning the area, small areas (i.e. patches) may only need a few hundred grafts and obtaining the hair by FUE may be a very reasonable method. If there is a large area of bald scalp that needs coverage then I am of the opinion that obtaining a strip is a better method and yields more grafts. In my hands I can get more viable grafts with a strip method than the FUE method.
Hope this was helpful.
Follicular Unit Transplant
Follicular Unit Transplant (FUT) is a process where a thin strip of hair is taken from a donor site on the scalp and the donor site is surgically closed. Hair from above the incision covers the area so that the scar is not visible. The donor strip is then placed under a microscope and dissected into individual follicular units of one to four hairs. Recipient sites are created with a small instrument and individual follicular units are placed into these tiny openings.This process aesthetically improves the density of existing hair, lowers the hairline or fills in balding areas, producing a very natural appearance.
Web reference: http://www.hairtransplantalabama.com/
It Depends On Your Needs
Follicular unit extraction and strip harvesting are both legitimate methods of harvesting hair for follicular unit grafting. The best method will depend on your needs, your budget, and your ability to deal with scars vs. thinning. FUE will necessarily thin the area that is harvested, require longer sessions to obtain large numbers of grafts, and have a significantly higher cost. Strip harvesting will leave a scar but this is easily covered by the hair in the back of the scalp, is currently the gold standard for treatment, and can be used over and over in the same spot. As always, talking with an experienced hair transplant surgeon is critical to determine what is best for your situation.
These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.