How Durable Are Saline Implants if a Bad Fall is Taken? I Ride Horses and Am Afraid To Rupture Them.

asked 3 months ago by KM85 in Quakertown, PA
Latest answer by Mahlon Kerr, MD
Question viewed 134 times
Tags: saline implants, strength, subpectoral

I am a horseback rider & I compete & do a lot of jumping, not just a casual trail rider. My biggest worry is taking a fall & breaking the saline implants. They are going to be subpectoral. Falls do happen, not usually on the chest, but I am still stressing over the fact that I might rupture them. How durable are saline implants & can they withstand a bad fall? I haven't had the surgery yet, this is the biggest drawback for me, worrying that I won't be able to jump anymore due to the risk!

9 answers to How Durable Are Saline Implants if a Bad Fall is Taken? I Ride Horses and Am Afraid To Rupture Them.

Saline implants will hold up to a bad fall

What the saline and the silicone gel implant have in common is the silicone elastomer rubber shell. Both implants will hold up to bad fall very well. You should be able to do what you wish without any thought about the implant. Best of luck, peterejohnsonmd.com

Peter E. Johnson, MD
Chicago Plastic Surgeon

www.peterejohnsonmd.com

How Durable Are Saline Implants if a Bad Fall is Taken? I Ride Horses and Am Afraid To Rupture Them.

Have no fear...get back up on that horse after!!! These implants are very durable and I have a number of patients that ride (and fall!) here in AZ. Certainly just riding is fine and you would have to have a direct fall onto your chest to possibly do any damage but many of us have very active patients and they do fine!!!

John J. Corey, MD
Phoenix Plastic Surgeon

Implants and durability

Implants are very durable. Sure, if you take a very big hit to your chest, they can rupture, just like your ribs can break.

Steven Wallach, MD
Manhattan Plastic Surgeon

Saline Implants durable enough to survive a fall?

Saline implants are very durable and quite difficult to break even with a significant fall. In fact, it usually takes so much trauma to break an implant, that it is actually probably protective of your chest wall if you do crash. I would not worry about this. You are getting saline implants which, if one ruptures, is a relatively easy thing to replace, and the only thing that comes out of it is saline. Unless you are getting a quite large implant that could interfere with your... more

Braden Stridde, MD
Federal Way Plastic Surgeon

What Causes Rupture of Saline Implants?

Women are often worried that their breast implants may not stand up to their vigorous athletic activity. No implant in the human body lasts forever, whether it be a breast implant , a total hip replacement or heart valve. When a saline implant ruptures it is most often caused by a "crease fold failure." That means a wrinkle in the implant rubs against another wrinkle. Chronic friction creates a thin spot that eventually leaks. This is more common... more

Mary Lee Peters, MD
Seattle Plastic Surgeon

www.maryleepetersmd.com

Implant rupture from horseback riding

RIding a horse would not rupture your implants, but if you fell off the horse, particularly at high speed, it could produce enough blunt trauma to rupture the implants. I have seen several cases in which patients involved in motor vehicle accidents reported deflation immediately after the trauma. This is definitely a consideration for you to evaluate in making a decision for surgery.

Robert L. Kraft, MD
New York Plastic Surgeon

Implant Ruptures Not Usually Associated With Trauma

Most implant (both saline and silicone) ruptures occur without any history of trauma. In fact, in over 25 years of performing augmentations, I cannot recall any which could be directly associated with any sort of trauma. Most implant ruptures are due to small defects which develop in the seams of the implants and ruptures are due more to bad luck than to lifestyles.

John Whitt, MD
Louisville Plastic Surgeon

Breast Implant Rupture and Horseback Riding?

Thank you for the question. Breast implants are very durable; it will require significant force/trauma to cause a rupture. However, falling off a horse and landing on your chest certainly may generate enough pressure/impact to cause a rupture. Ultimately, you will have to weigh your desire to have the procedure done versus the probability that you will experience such an impact/fall. Most of my or horse back riding patients would agree with... more

Tom J. Pousti, MD
San Diego Plastic Surgeon

Implant rupture from a fall?

I grew up on a small equestrian facility with a mother obsessed with hunter/jumper and fairly aggressive trail riding. She has broken a few bones so I understand where your concern comes from. That being said implant shells are quite strong and also very protected by your breast and the pectoral muscle. I have seen many terrible injuries sustained by women with breast implants from car and other accidents and none caused a rupture except a gun shot wound-yikes! The moral of the story is that... more