I've had 2 consults for a full TT with breast implants. Both surgeons were highly recommended, board certified, 30+ yrs experience. One uses quilting sutures, no drains and lipo to sculpt entire area. Other surgeon uses drains and very Iimited lipo. Of course I'd prefer no drains and I think I'd need lipo on the upper abdomen to get a smooth result. But is this way of doing it safe? Are there increased risks? And if not, why don't all surgeons do quilting method? (I'm 39, 5'3", 123#, healthy)
Drains or Quilting Sutures for TT?
Doctor Answers (14)
Drains or Quilting Sutures for Tummy Tuck?
Not having drain tubes after Tummy Tuck surgery is obviously a very attractive proposition. The quilting sutures are NOT new and have been with us for over 10 years. The questions are: does it work in everyone? What are the consequences of NOT using drains?
I was trained to do Tummy Tuck surgery with the use of drains. Years later, I switched to the use of quilting sutures as proposed by Drs. Pollock of Dallas and used various configurations with and without drains. I even used such quilting sutures without drains after spraying the wound with Fibrin glue to promote faster adherence of the walls. After encountering a series of fluid collections (seromas) and having to perform multiple syringe aspirations in these women I have given this up and returned to the use of drains. My seroma rates have then plummeted to less than 5%.
Plastic surgeons are NOT conservative in nature and try new things ALL the time (driving our OR nurses who hate change crazy). I suspect the middle age and older surgeons share my experience. The younger guys will eventually join us as well in seeing the wisdom of drains.
I hope this answered your question.
Peter A Aldea, MD
Why not BOTH drain and quilting sutures?
This is not how you choose a surgeon! A drain is useful to reduce fluid that collects in the cavity created by raising the skin flaps. Quilting sutures help to tack the skin flap down, but cannot completely eliminate the residual "dead space" where fluid collects. Why not use both, reducing the length of time the drain has to be left in, and increasing the likelihood that once it is removed that there is sufficient healing to prevent fluid from reaccumulating and aspiration via needle stick being necessary? When liposuction is performed with tummy tuck, the surgeon has to be careful to avoid damaging the blood supply to the lower abdominal skin by over-aggressive suctioning of the upper abdominal areas through which these blood vessels flow. Also, lipo increases the fluid that the body (or drain) must deal with. The vast majority of plastic surgeons use drains with tummy tucks; when lipo is added, I suspect the number goes up even more!
Just because some surgeons use quilting sutures and no drains does NOT mean they never have fluid accumulation, for which aspiration or later drain placement is necessary! Oh, but then you lose the "marketing" aspect of being able to say "I don't use drains; I use quilting sutures!" If a surgeon asserts this, then you should ask them if they EVER have had fluid collect in a TT patient, or if they EVER had to place a drain later. Maybe they just ignore the fluid. See questions about seroma here on RS for these surgeons' patients!
Denial is not a river in Egypt! I'd go with the surgeon who does limited suction and uses a drain; he sounds safer to me! But you talked with both of them; listen to your head and your gut!
Tummy tuck is safe without drains
Tummy tuck is safe without drains with a very low complication rate. It seems by reviewing this site that the techniques are controversial, though tummy tuck without drains is widely practiced, and the techniques are published, and repeated by many. You can have a great result with or without a drain, and the key issue is which surgeon do you put your trust and faith in. A drain is a secondary concern.
Best of luck,
You might also like...
New way of doing a tummy tuck - NO DRAINS
The use of quilting sutures is becoming more and more popular. This technique does not require the use of post-surgical drains and is perfectly safe and acceptable. I have been performing all tummy tucks for about 18 months now and I am very happy with the outcomes. Some surgeons have not yet considered the use of quilting sutures or just don't feel comfortable to change a technique that has worked for them for many years. It doesn't mean that the newer technique is in any way inferior.
Martin Jugenburg, MD
Go with whoever you feel confortable with
Each surgeon has his/ her way of doing tummy tuck. Just choose the one that you feel confortable with. The drain should not your biggest concern.
Drains or sutures..
As you can see from the 3 surgeons responding to your question, there are varying opinions on this issue. Surgical judgement is based on individual surgeon's training, experience, and published scientific data. I have been using progressive tension sutures (PTS) with no drains for over thiry years without a single case of post op fluid accumulation (seroma). We recently published nearly 600 consecutive cases of TT using PTS and NO drains, with only one small seroma (required a single aspiration). The use of the PTS greatily improves the over patient experience---No cumbersome drains, no need to bend over while standing and walking, and better mobiitity after surgery, since the sutures prevent disruption of early healing. While our data shows the effectiveness of this suture technique, without using drains, the use of drains with PTS is the surgeons prerogative . Your question "why don't all surgeons do quilting method?" is a frequent one we hear from our patients and one which I can't answer. However, since we introduced PTS in 2000 in a published article, we have been gratified to see increasing acceptance of this technique .us, but most important
Drains with tummy tuck
Either method is acceptable. I have gone back to using drains because of concerns over seromas(fluid collections). I will suction the upper abdomen at the same time, but some surgeons are hesitant to do so. If I suction, then I think the drains are even more important.
Since either method works, I would choose the surgeon you feel most comfortable with.
Drains or Quilting Sutures for TT?
Here Here for Dr. Rand. Drains are for prevention of accumulation of fluids. Quitting is a suture technique that has become a media issue. In my opinion over 90% of boarded PS use some form of drains in TTs. Only 5% use quitting. You do the math, chose upon experience. From MIAMI
Tummy tuck, liposuction and quilting sutures
Both approaches are be reasonable. When it comes to liposuction during an abdominoplasty, it can be safely performed in most patients when done in the deeper planes. This will usually result in a thinner and more sculpted final result. As far as quilting sutures go, it can allow avoidance of drains with probably a minimal risk of seroma formation. Most surgeons are simply used to using drains only. Also, plication sutures add more surgical time which may be seen as a drawback.
Need individual plan for tummy tuck.
1) I don't exactly agree with either surgeon. One should not do the same operation on different women. Also, the final decision about drains is often best made during surgery. Here are some general concepts:
2) We do use quilting sutures on most patients. You have to learn to do it, and it makes the operation a little longer, but they are a good thing. They distribute skin tension and decrease drainage.
3) We do quite a bit of liposuction of the upper abdomen and of the love handles on most women. It can dramatically improve shape. For this to be safe, you need to do a " minimal undermining" tummy tuck to preserve the blood supply to the skin.
4) Sometimes we just use quilting sutures, and sometimes we use quilting sutures and drains. It is not either or. Liposuction increases drainage, so we are more likely to use drains when we have done a lot of liposuction. Drains are uncomfortable for a few days, but they are not terrible. We do whatever we can to prevent a seroma..
These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.