Advice on fixing capsular contracture in right breast?

I had breast implants in June 2006. Before I had my implants put in, I was very asymmetrical. I had implants put in 600cc's on the right and 475 cc on the left over the muscle. I now have a grade 3 capsule on the right. I have had 3 consultations, and 2 of the surgoens want to put in silicone and go bigger. The other one wants to fill the left to 600cc's, put in a new implant on right, and fill to 725cc's. My nipples line up, so no lift is required on left. Implants are too big to go under now. I want to have them redone ASAP! What would you advise?

3 answers to “Advice on fixing capsular...”

A: Change the position of the implant and change the implants.

By Lavinia Chong, MD - Orange County Plastic Surgeon

Sorry to hear about your problem. Most PS agree that if you've developed a Baker III capsular contracture, surgical treatment should include removal of the scar capsule (capsulectomy), implant exchange (possibly to silicone gel) and conversion to another plane, in your case, on top to below the chest... more

A: with a capsule on an implant above the muscle consider going below with a textured device

By John E. Gross, MD - Los Angeles Plastic Surgeon

The treatment options for patients with capsular contracture may involve thinking in terms of "trade-offs". It is pretty universally believed that in patients undergoing surgery for capsular contracture with implants above the muscle the chance of recurrence is less if new implants are... more

A: Going bigger over the muscle with silicone may give more contracture

By John P. Di Saia, MD - Orange County Plastic Surgeon

Hello, Contracture relates to the choice of a silicone gel and relatively little tissue to cover pretty large implants. You likely need a capsulectomy and new implants. If you go with large "Overs" again, it will likely recur. It sounds like you need more opinions.