Is a Breast Lift Necessary for Me if I Get An Augmentation? (photo)

34-yr-o mom of 3, 5'7", 118. 1st consult ystrdy, utterly taken aback by opinion that I "NEEDED" lift or my results would be aweful. I found this unexpected n terrifying. Pass the pencil test barely, did not think I needed lift, because of small size thought an implant would fill enough to do the trick. Have more consults but really need much advice. Lift scars terrify me n goal was to look in mirror n feel good finally, not make matters worse.  Example of what I xpected posted

Doctor Answers 16

Lift or filling

The answer is, it depends. If you get a small implant, then a lift may be necessary, but if you go with a larger size, it may give you the improvement you need. A larger implant (over 350ccs) may fill you up enough so that you look as if your breasts have been lifted. Also  you do not want to put the implants under the muscle.

New York Plastic Surgeon
4.0 out of 5 stars 9 reviews

Have a question? Ask a doctor

Breast Lift or Augmentation Alone


The picture you sent is hard to perfectly evaluate, but you do appear similar in your picture to the other patient picture that you have provided. While no two people are alike, it is quite possible that you will have a similar result. I have found that many patients who I originally thought "had" to have a lift, in fact looked fine after just an augment alone. As long as you understand that your nipples will be lower on the breasts (as they are now), then the augment can provide you with the volume that you are seeking. In cases such as yours I sometimes use sub glandular silicone implants to really expand the breast envelope and provide a lift from within (so to speak). I hope this helps.


Daniel Medalie, MD

Breast lift and augmentation

Remember an augmentation does not produce a lift.  A small lift whether just an areola one or a vertical may be beneficial.

Steven Wallach, MD
Manhattan Plastic Surgeon
4.5 out of 5 stars 18 reviews

Is a lift needed?

Don't panic. You've only had one consult. Whether or not you need a lift depends on the result that you are looking for. Your nipples are a little low and would remain so without a lift. But the posy op photos you show are nice and I would anticipate that you would get the same type of result without a lift. Don't feel forced into something you don't want as long as you are realistic with the results that you will get from what you want. Get more consults and check out their photos until you find a surgeon who can deliver what you want. If they all say that you need a lift than it may be time to reconsider. 

Do I really need a breast lift? (photos)

Although it is only a best guess from your submitted photo and the info. provided (pencil test), my best guess is that you can indeed achieve the desired result without formal mastopexy.  Depends on how much your inframammary crease is lowered, diameter of selected implants, how your augmentation is done, etc.  Can always defer mastopexy and have it later if absolutely necessary. Even if you need it, will likely be peri-areolar, barely visible (and revisable) scars.

Steve Laverson, MD
San Diego Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 40 reviews

Breast lift

Looking at the front picture is not enough to answer this question. A side view and breast measurements are needed. Based on 10 years of working as a plastic surgeon and looking only at the frontal view my gut tells me you need a lift. No one wants to hurt your feelings, they want you to be happy with your results. Set up a few consultations with board cetified plastic surgeons and good luck!

Gregory Lynam, MD
Richmond Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 28 reviews

Lift and augment

The pencil test measures the amount of tissue along the chest wall and does not give an indication of whether a lift is needed because it doesn't recognize the location of the nipples. I agree with others that without side view photos, we would simply be guessing on whether the lift should be performed. However, despite the trepidation expressed by many patients on this forum about lift scarring, my patient satisfaction rate is extremely high. Scars will fade but the decisions you make in an effort to avoid scarring can have lasting consequences. There are a variety of mastopexy variations and I would encourage you to see more doctors in consultation and clearly define your surgical goals.

Robert L. Kraft, MD
New York Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 16 reviews

Pass the pencil test, a lift is optional

We are with you. The pre picture is very much like you, and the after would be a pretty good bet. If you pass the pencil test the lift is optional, and the scar may not be worth the effort. Implants alone will make you happy.

Peter E. Johnson, MD
Chicago Plastic Surgeon
4.0 out of 5 stars 33 reviews

Do I need a lift?

Certainly an augmentation alone can fill out empty-appearing breasts.  What it won't do is to lift the breast tissue (or nipple/areola).  If you would be satisfied with simply filling the tissue you have, then you don't need a lift.  Certainly, get more professional opinions to help you with this decision.

Michael Leff, MD
Bellevue Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 6 reviews

Is a lift necessary?

If you want to avoid a lift you can certainly begin with augmentation alone; wait 3 months for full settling to occur and then decide if a lift is something you want to do.  It looks from your picture as if you have an excess of skin: achieving perfect skin-volume balance may not be possible without a lift unless you have huge implants placed.  I suggest coming to an agreement with your surgeon re: size of implant and then deciding about the lift later on.  If you only want to be in the OR one time then bite the scar bullet and consider a lift now to get the best possible result in one fell swoop.

These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.