Arnica Montana Not Good for First Time Rhinoplasty?

I had rhinoplasty two days ago. When I asked about Arnica Montana, here was my nurse's response: "Please stop arnica, we did a study on patients who were having their nose done for the first time and the end result was those that took Arnica pills had more bleeding, bruising and swelling. The product it should not be ingested and is meant to be used in a cream base form." I understand that I am to follow what my doctor says, but this seems to be a huge discrepancy. Please help.

Tags:

Comment on this

3 Doctor Answers | Asked by KathleenRsmith411 in Grand Rapids, MI

Doctor Answers (3)
Community Comments (0)

Arnica Use In Rhinoplasty

There is no evidence that taking Arnica causes worse bruising after a primary rhinoplasty. Whether it will reduce the bruising is a matter of debate, but its low cost and lack of any side effects makes its use common. If you have visible bruising from osteotomies, you can use both the tablets and the cream. There is no harm in doing both.

Arnica Montana for rhinoplasty

We have found some do benefit from the use of Arnica to reduce bruising after rhinoplasty, however the supplement is not studied and of a 'proven' benefit. We often reccommend Arnica, and some will follow, however bottom line is that you will do well with or without the supplemental. By the way, the tablets are what we suggest, as the cream will not penetrate the skin well.

Arnica Montana in Rhinoplasty Patients

I would disagree with this nurse's statement regarding the role of Arnica in the rhinoplasty healing process. I have been using Arnica in the peri-operative period for years and have noted a marked reduction overall in terms of postoperative swelling and bruising. I think a good majority of my colleagues would have the same sentiments. At the end of the day, though, you should follow the instructions of your chosen rhinoplasty surgeon. Happy healing.