Is African American Rhinoplasty too complex?

I'm a black American female who is considering Rhinoplasty. I went to a well accredited doctor that told me I should not get it done as it would be close to impossible for me to have a narrower nose.

I have high nostrils that are also very large and he said it would be a very complex procedure and if done the result would be minimal. I really would like my nostrils to be oval shaped and dramatically narrower. So is this true? Should I give up or do I have hope?

Is African American Rhinoplasty too complex?
Sort: Date | Helpful
6 answers to “Is African American Rhinoplasty too...”

A: He might be right

William B. Rosenblatt, MD

You can't always get what you want. Look at Michael Jackson -- I don't believe that his nose is much of an improvement over what he started with. You don't have to give up after one consultation, but see someone who has a lot of experience in noses and african american noses. They are a specific challenge.... more

A: African American Rhinoplasty can be very difficult but not impossible

Manish H. Shah, MD

Some of the characteristics of African American nasal skin are increased thickness and increased fatty content, especially at the tip. The base of the nose can also be quite wide with flaring of the nostrils.   It is not easy to adjust all these areas without extensive surgery because the skin can prevent... more

A: See a Physician who knows african-american rhinoplasty

Robert M. Jensen, MD

I would seek out a physician who is comfortable and has done a number of African-American rhinoplasties.  These are not more difficult, just different in the techniques used.  Excellent results can be obtained by a well qualified "rhinoplasty" surgeon.

A: Don't give it up!

Toby G. Mayer, MD

 See an experienced rhinoplasty surgeon who does good black noses. It is a complex operation for a surgeon who does only an occasional black nose. But for doctors who do large numbers and good subtle black noses, it is not complex.

A: Feminization and refinement of nose is possible

William Portuese, MD

In considering an African-American rhinoplasty, there are many things that can be done with a tipped bridge to effect a change such as feminization and refinement, yet still keeping the African-American ethnicity to the nose. Narrowing of the nasal bridge, along with refinement of the tip, and alarplasties to... more

A: African American Rhinoplasty

Oleh Slupchynskyj, MD

Hi, African american rhinoplasty is a subspecialty of rhinoplasty in my mind. The african american nose differs from any other nose because the anatomy is different.  The birdge is typically low and wide, the tip is bulbous with an amorphous quality and the nostrils tend to flare. There are many... more

Community Discussions

Q&A Forum about "Is African American Rhinoplasty too complex?"
DiscussionReplies

Be the first to start a discussion

Rhinoplasty: 448 reviews

68% said it was worth it

Rhinoplasty before & after photos

Rhinoplasty cost near you Rhinoplasty cost map



Rhinoplasty: was it worth it?
IMPORTANT: As noted in our Terms of Service, the information found on RealSelf.com, including that provided by professionals in the Questions & Answers area, is a general educational aid. The Questions and Answers contain opinions and views created by community members. RealSelf.com is not responsible for the accuracy of any information posted by community members. Do not rely on this information as a substitute for personal medical or healthcare advice, or for diagnosis or treatment purposes.