Hi,
The truth of the matter is that it really depends. Depending on the amount of ptosis (droop) you have of the nipple and areola, it may be better to stage the procedure. In patient's that have severe ptosis, I usually counsel them to have the lift first, wait a few months, and then have implants. If they protest loudly enough, I may relent and perform it in one stage, but advise them that there's a relatively high rate of revision (scar revision, additional lift, etc).
In more than 80% of patients, though, I feel comfortable combining a lollipop lift with simultaneous breast implant placement.
Bottom line - it really comes down to physician preference and comfort. Different surgeons do things in different ways and get great results. Assuming both of the doctors are board-certified plastic surgeons, choose the one in whom you have the most confidence.
Best of luck.





