Silicone implants give better results.

George J. Beraka, MD answers: Silicone vs. Saline: Implant Replacement after Capsular Contracture

I'm 28, and I have 425cc Saline breast implants with a capsular contracture ("CC") on my right side. It's severe and painful, and will need to be removed. My doctor suggested replacing the saline with silicone. He said that there is only a 1% chance of the CC occuring again. Is that true? Which should I go for? I also am planning to go smaller, so both implants will be replaced.


George J. Beraka, MD
12 months ago

Silicone implants in general look and feel more natural.  But you can get another capsular contracture with any kind  of implant, and the risk is more like 5%.

How the surgery is done is more important than what implant you use. Even without seeing you, I can tell you that going smaller is a good idea.  You need to have part of the capsule removed to release the contracture (called a capsulectomy)  and you also need the pocket made smaller to accomodate the smaller implant (called a capsulorrhaphy).

Even a tiny amount of bleeding can cause capsular contracture, so control of bleeding has to be meticulous. I would consider using drains for you.

Also, even a very low grade infection that you cannot detect can cause capsular contracture.  So, the wounds need to be irrigated with antibiotic solution, and you need to get antibiotics by vein.

These are just a couple of examples of surgical details that matter so much.

2 of 2 found this helpful
Helpful?

A: The rate is higher

Steven Wallach, MD
12 months ago

The rate of capsular contracture is much higher than 1% for patients that have had a previous CC.  Some studies suggest it is about 20-30%, and may even be higher.

Post your question
IMPORTANT: As noted in our Terms of Service, the information found on RealSelf.com, including that provided by professionals in the Questions & Answers area, is a general educational aid. The Questions and Answers contain opinions and views created by community members. RealSelf.com is not responsible for the accuracy of any information posted by community members. Do not rely on this information as a substitute for personal medical or healthcare advice, or for diagnosis or treatment purposes.