SmartLipo vs Traditional Liposuction

Theodore Katz, MD answers: Liposuction vs. SmartLipo - which is better?

I have been to two doctors, one wants to do smart lipo and one is a plastic surgeon and said smart lipo is not as good and performs only traditional liposuctions. How can I decide which is the best choice?


Theodore Katz, MD
4 months ago

"If all you have is a hammer, the whole world looks like a nail"!  If a surgeon only does traditional or tumescent liposuction, then oftentimes he/she is prejudiced toward that procedure and will negate any references to other techniques as "not proven" or unsubstantiated, or the other surgeon has a "vested" interest.

I have no financial stakes in any complany providing laser assisted lipo equipment.  I do not take honorariums from such companies.  I do, however, evaluate newer techniques and technologies and will apply them if I can see an advantage to the patient.  Any new technology must be compared to the "gold standard" - in this case traditional or tumescent liposuction.  I do perform these techniques when necessary.  I have used SmartLipo extensively, and have evaluated SlimLipo and ProLipo (these are all laser assisted liposuction/liposculpture technologies).  These technologies do have a role. 

They are just tools in the armamentariuum of the plastic surgeon specializing in body contouring.  The more tools that one has, the surgeon can apply the one that is best for his patient.  Traditional and laser assisted techniques each have their roles.  If a patient has a limited area of lipodystrophy (abnormal distribution of fat in an area that is resistant to change with dieting and exercise), and if the patient is close to their ideal weight, then I would recommend the laser assisted techniques. 

They can be done under local anesthesia, with minimal sedation, and they do work!  There definitely is some tightening of the skin as well.  This has been especially demonstrated by patients of mine that have had excess skin of the neck and very little fat, but with laserassisted techniques the skin has been tightened.  The down time is less, there is less pain and swelling than traditional techniques. 

In the final analysis, you want the surgeon to do what he/she feels comfortable in doing and that achieve your desired results.  Laser assisted liposculpture is NOT for everyone or every case and it needs to be individualized.  Get a second por even third opinion, but fo with the surgeon with whom your gut tells you is best for you.  There is a lot of hype with newer technologies, lasers included.  Go to a board certified plastic surgeon with experience in body contouring and mulktiple modalities of treatment.

9 of 9 found this helpful
Helpful?

Request info from Dr. Katz

Special offers
Buy one, get one 1/2 off laser hair
buy 1 laser hair removal pkg. of 6 treatments, get the 2nd pkg for 50% off.
Expires Nov 29 2009
Free Facial
come in for a free consultation and get a free facial.
Expires Nov 29 2009
Buy Latisse, get a free facial
Buy a box of Latisse eyelash treatment and receive a free facial.
Expires Dec 30 2009
Offers don't imply eligibility for a medical procedure. All applicable federal, state and local laws apply. Void where prohibited.
50 words maximum (0 words entered)
Your info is protected by our privacy policy
Post your question

Liposuction: 214 reviews

62% said it was worth it

Liposuction before & after photos

Post your question
IMPORTANT: As noted in our Terms of Service, the information found on RealSelf.com, including that provided by professionals in the Questions & Answers area, is a general educational aid. The Questions and Answers contain opinions and views created by community members. RealSelf.com is not responsible for the accuracy of any information posted by community members. Do not rely on this information as a substitute for personal medical or healthcare advice, or for diagnosis or treatment purposes.