It's the facelift surgeon that matters, not the specific facelift technique.

Hi!

This is very confusing and scary for patients, bur there is no magic in a particular facelift technique.  You can get a terrible result from a poorly executed composite facelift. 

It is the skill and artistry of the individual surgeon that determine the result.  Try to talk to patients who are happy and who don't look pulled.

To answer your question about composite face lift, one has to first understand the difference between the various types of face lifts. 

1. Mini face lift.  The least invasive of the lifts.  It involves a shorter incision.  In addition, most of the lift comes from removing excess skin rather than lifting the deeper SMAS layer.  Results are less dramatic.  These are ideal for younger patients who need minimal results.  Results can look unnatural and pulled if too much tension is placed on the skin especially in older patients where a deeper lift would have been a better approach as the skin can't hold up the sagging SMAS and deeper facial structures.
2. SMAS face lift.  This involves tightening the deeper facial structures.  It is less invasive than a deep plane face lift as the SMAS is not separated (or to a minimal extent) from the underlying facial muscles.  Sutures are used to tuck the SMAS at a higher level.  This is approach is safer than the deeper lift  but at a price- there is less lifting of the mid face and toning of the jaw line. This type of lift is easier to perform than a deep plane lift.
3. Deep plane lift.  The SMAS layer is separated from the underlying facial muscles and sutured at a higher position on the face.  This gives more of a lift along the mid face and jaw line than a standard SMAS lift.  There is a slightly higher risk of facial nerve injury.  This procedure should be performed by plastic surgeons who have a lot of experience with this technique.  There is an ongoing debate as to superiority of results vs your SMAS lift.  In my opinion, results are superior along the jaw line and cheeks which have more of a lift.  Neither the SMAS or Deep plane lift have a substantial effect on the nasolabial folds (parenthesis lines) and fillers are used to smooth those out in both cases.
4. Subperiostial face lift.  This is not a popular technique as it results in prolonged swelling.  In this technique the entire mid face is lifted off the cheek bone in an endoscopic (small temple incision) approach.  It works well to lift the cheeks but falls short in treating the neck and jaw line.  It can be combined with a SMAS lift if the surgeons wants to use the subperiostial lift to lift the cheeks rather than the deep plane approach (for the cheek lift)

There are two types of deep plane face lifts.

1. Multiplanar Deep Plane Lift: the skin and SMAS are lifted independently from the underlying muscle. 
2. Composite Deep Plane Lift:  the skin and SMAS are lifted as one layer.  This is less than ideal in that a) it will often result in raising of the temple hairline and b) the ideal direction of lift for the SMAS layer is different from that of the skin.  If they are lifted as one layer, the two vectors can't be established.  It is for this reason that the Multiplanar Deep Plane lift is more popular than the composite deep plane lift.

One final note.  It is not so much the type of lift that determines the end result but the skill of the surgeon and the use of other concomitant rejuvenating procedures to balance out the rejuvenation process.  In addition, I wouldn't would use viewing pre and post op photos from prospective surgeons more as a tool to see if you find their results esthetically pleasing and not overdone.  The type of face lift used is less important in viewing these photos.  I would agree, that it would be helpful to see the photos 3 to 5 years out from the procedure but this is usually not possible as many patients don't come back after their final post op visit for additional photos. The modern day face lift utilizes volume restoration as the cornerstone to a more natural lift.  Less lifting is needed once lost volume is replaced with either fat, Sculptra or other products.  Youthful skin adds a lot to a face lift result.  My preferred skin resurfacing approach is with Fraxel laser.  Remember, a face lift doesn't rejuvenate the skin.

I hope this is helpful.

Good luck.

1 of 1 found this helpful

Helpful?

Contact the doctor

Surgeons tend to have a "favorite" facelift technique that they feel works best for them. However, not all patients are created equal. Some have more drooping than others, some have wider faces and the skin varies as well. So, you should seek out a facelift specialist to determine which is best for your. Of course, surgeons will put their best results in a website or book. It is a matter of deciding who you feels understands your needs and can deliver a quality, natural result.

Helpful?

Contact the doctor

Not having read the book, I have to disagree that there is only one way to do a facelift. That's like saying, if you have only on hammer  everything is a nail. You must have more than one tool in your toolbox to fix things. Composite facelift are right for one kind of patient and a minilift is right for another.

For example, a busy executive that has minimal excess of the jowl and neck area but doesn't have time to recovery for 3 to 4 weeks will do great with a minifacelift.  As long as the surgeon is upfront with the limitations of the procedure and the patient understand, then this is the right procedure. On the other hand, if a patient has excessive jowling and neck excess then a minifacelift will not be the appropriate procedure. Whether the patient has a composite lift or any other type of  extensive facelift, they have to be ready for the cost and recovery time.

There was a scientific study comparing SMAS flap ( elevation of the face muscle) vs. plication of the SMAS in the same patient and showed no difference in the outcome of either techniques.

So in short, the right procedure for the right patient with the right surgeon. Every patient is unique and will require a slightly different procedure.

Lastly, your surgeon should be able to perform any of the procedures and be able to explain and offer them to you, understanding the limitations, risks and outcomes.

Best,

Dr.S.

Helpful?

Contact the doctor