Avoid the "open roof" deformity

David C. Pearson, MD answers: Filing down the dorsal hump?

I have a small dorsal hump that I would like to get fixed on my nose, and was considering closed rhinoplasty. The plastic surgeon informed me that he could just go in and file it down without breaking or fracturing any bones. Does this sound like a good idea? The absolute only thing I want done is the hump shaved down, and it is very small. Will any other part of my nose need fixing if the surgeon simply files the hump down?


David C. Pearson, MD
11 months ago

As one of my colleagues below touched on, the problem with "only" rasping down the nasal bones is that the nasal bones and cartilage are quite thin--a few millimeters, really--so that anything more significant than a tiny hump will require rasping right through those thin plates of bone and cartilage. This creates what is known as an "open roof" deformity, which can become unsightly over time. To close the open roof requires cuts in the bone where the nasal bones meet the facial bones (well, the nasal processes of the maxillae).

I'm often surprised, though, by the term "breaking" the bones, which implies a brutal, imprecise, and painful process. Osteotomies--literally, bone cutting--should be precise, delicate, and minimally traumatic. Besides, even without osteotomies, the rasping of the bones and soft-tissue dissection required for even closed rhinoplasty is still a significant surgical procedure. The least of a patient's concern should be the osteotomies, if the patient is in the hands of a competent surgeon. The focus should always be on achieving a safe, natural, unoperated result that can withstand the test of time.

3 of 3 found this helpful
Helpful?

Request info from Dr. Pearson

50 words maximum (0 words entered)
Your info is protected by our privacy policy
More answers to Filing down the dorsal hump?

A: Correction of a small hump on the nose

Scott Trimas, MD
4 months ago

Correction of a small hump on the nose can be as simple as just filing the area down gently with a rasp under local or IV anesthesia. However, in some patients if it is a larger hump a flattening effect to the dorsum may result called an "open roof" and this might require breaking or infracturing the two nasal side bones to close the area that was filed down to prevent a flattened appearance. Even if the additional surgery is required it is considered minimal and shouldn't take the surgeon much longer to perform.

2 of 2 found this helpful
Helpful?
Post your question

Rhinoplasty: 349 reviews

68% said it was worth it

Rhinoplasty before & after photos

Post your question
IMPORTANT: As noted in our Terms of Service, the information found on RealSelf.com, including that provided by professionals in the Questions & Answers area, is a general educational aid. The Questions and Answers contain opinions and views created by community members. RealSelf.com is not responsible for the accuracy of any information posted by community members. Do not rely on this information as a substitute for personal medical or healthcare advice, or for diagnosis or treatment purposes.