Scar Removal Forum
69%
WORTH IT RATING
"Worth It Rating" shows the % of consumer reviewers that stated the procedure was "Worth It" or not. See more RealSelf Worth It Ratings or Add Your Review
Scar Removalbefore & after photos
View Before and Afters

Average Scar Removal Cost: $1,860

Learn about Scar Removal

1,382 people and 359 doctors are talking about Scar Removal

Get Free Email Updates

Keloid removal with string?

By RyeeGuy on 19 Mar 2009

I was reading someone saying that they tied a string around their earlobe keloid to cut off the circulation and the keloid dried up. I was wondering, does it really work?

View 7 doctor answers to Tying String Around Ear Keloid for Removal?

Comments (693)

Post a Comment Sort:
ms. already tried (unregistered guest) 28 Apr 2009
whatever you do dont do it. my keloid on my ear didnt start growing until i was pregnant. there was not much that could be done then so i put a rubber band around it very bad idea. it hurt and i couldnt get it off cause it was so tight. i had to get a knife a cut it off (very dangerous and stupid decision I made)
kid gone27 31 Jul 2010
i did that did your grow back?
AlmostfreeAtlast 17 Nov 2011
While the site is real and information is provided by ordinary peopl just like you and me. I really can't give you any advice in your situation but I'm glad to report that the string or rubberband method does work! ;) I'm still in the early stages after my keloid removal. Therefore. I can't say whether it has or had not returned yet... And in regards to ur acne look into the oil cleansing method usinga mixture of castor oil in addition to another essential oil like olive oil, sunflower oil, etc...
NeverenderMyStory 5 Apr 2012
did you expect this procedure to a painless piece of cake? this crap is painful...but it works..i am living proof!
Yellow Sunshine 1 May 2009
I'm trying this method at the moment. It is certainly drying it up. I can feel the keloid getting looser and looser everyday, which I'm happy for. It can be rather messy though; as the string is cutting into the skin, pus and blood are appearing, but its coming off! I have been stringing my keloid now for 3 weeks, hopefully another 3 weeks and it will be removed!
KeloidKrazy 14 Jul 2010
How long did the pain continue?
Buck harris 18 Jul 2009
Yellow so how is it going now I want to do the same thing how long does it take to fall off
Brandon Oneal 29 Jul 2009
I want to know how long does it take to fall off also. I've had a string on mines for a wk now and its starting to bleed and its swollen.
Mike D 10 Feb 2010
I just did this, I started on Friday and the keloid was dead by Wednesday. It wasn't falling off and had become infected so I cut it off to avoid blood poisoning or further infection. I'm now on antibiotics but my ear looks great. If you search youtube for "keloid death" there's a video on there showing how to do it. If you're scared to do it, you can start by using a rubber band then taking it off after a day, the keloid will swell up and then reduce to a smaller size. This is one way to slowly make it smaller. I did this three times before finally deciding to tie a string around it and get rid of it. To the first comment, it is true that you should have a high pain threshold to deal with this. The first two days the pain was exruciating, and I had to stack up on painkillers in order to sleep. Definitely worth it though.
KeloidKrazy 14 Jul 2010
Mike D, Please help me, I have been living a nightmare with these huge keloids on both ears. I had keloids when I was a kid from ear piercing and it was horrible then, I was always so ashamed and afraid someone would see them if my hair moved a certain way. My grandmother had them removed after 6 years of embarrassment. I was so happy. After years and years of no sign of a keloid, I got my ears pierced again. 10 years later after I got three more holes in each ear, they started to feel funny and I instantly thought about how ashamed I was years ago, so I took out the earrings and the holes closed up my ears felt normal again...whew, I was even left with the normal holes from 10 years ago. A year later I was pregnant and all of a sudden the holes that had closed up started to feel swollen and keloids were forming, soft keloids and small, but once I had the baby the swelling went away along with the keloids. Hurray! Pregnant again and this time those keloids started and never stopped even after having the baby they grew it seems like everyday, it has been a nightmare ever since. I have not had my hair up in my favorite style, a ponytail, in over 5 years. I am going crazy, It is so hot and I look nuts because I wear anything that will cover up these huge keloids. People think that I am nuts, because in 110 degree weather I will have a scarf, or furry hat on, sweating like a pig, but I cannot show these horrific keloids. So tonight I put the bands on and I was in tears because it hurt so bad, they were turning purple already, but I took of the rubberbands, I didn;t make it more than an hour, I took 4 advil pm's and they didnt work at all. I am going to try again, I have been researching and researching and this is the only option. Please let me know how many days does it take for the pain to subside, if the string is better than the rubberbands in your opinion, I used rubberbands and it hurt soooooooooooooooobad, also what medicine did you use? thanks, keloidkrazy
Mike D 10 Feb 2010
If you're having the problem Brandon has had, then your string has become too loose, which is why it has become to swell (the blood supply is no longer cut off). You need to cut off the string and tie it tighter.
applescruffs 28 Feb 2010
I had my ears pierced and I would wear hoop earings. I noticed when I wore the hoop earing on my left ear, it would stick out to the side, so I had my ear repierced but slightly inward so the hoop didnt stick out. In 2006 they pierced the hole right next to the existing one. Months later, I put the hoop in the previous hole which was slightly higher then the new hole. As I was brushing my hair the brush got got to the hoop and I ripped the earring to the next hole. This immediately caused a keloid but I didnt know it was a keloid. For the first few weeks I thought it was fluid and I tried poping it but nothing happened. As time went on it got bigger, I asked the doctor and thats when he told me it was a keloid, growing scare tissue from an injury. The doctor started the steriod injections into my ear on a monthly basis for 2 years but it didnt help at all. The doctor finally stopped because it wasnt working. He told me my only option was surgery but through a cosmetic clinic. He also warned me that if its removed, it could grow back. So all of 2009 I left the keloid alone and I noticed it started growing bigger. For months I've been researching on what I could do to get rid of it. I saw all the ads about gels, creams, patches but I didnt bother with them since the shots didnt work. I came across this website and read about tying a string around the ear. In a desperate attempt, I decided to tie a thin rubber band around my ear as tight as I could. I did it on Tuesday night 2/16/10. At first it got numb and blue. About 15 minutes later it started to hurt. About an hour later I wanted to take it off because it hurt so bad. But I know I did a good job at tying the keloid off, so I just took a Motrin 800 pill and about 45 minutes later the pain went away completely. The next day (Wednesday) the keloid was purple and about 3 pm the pain started coming back so I took another 800 pill and the pain went away. That was the last time I needed to take a pill. By Friday the keloid was totally black and hard. I knew it was dead. Saturday morning I took the rubber band off with intentions of cleaning it and putting the rubber band back on but it looked like it was getting infected. I got nervous so I went to see my doctor and he confirmed that it was not infected and only gave me ointment to put on my ear for when it did fall off. He even said I did a good job at killing the keloid but told me not to pull it off, just to wait for it to fall off in time. By that night the whole base of the keloid was black. It looked kind of gross so I wore a band aid on my ear to cover it. By the following Wednesday, the keloid fell off and I thought I'd have a big hole in my ear but I didnt. It looked like skin was already growing when the keloid fell off. So it took exactly 8 days for the keloid to fall off. Today is Sunday 03/01 and my husband, family, friends and co-workers are so surprised at how normal my ear looks. I would say its 85% healed and my ear lobe is flat, it doesnt feel like the keloid is going to come back. I just had to come back and post that it was a success for me. It was Mike D's post that gave me the confidence to do this. Yes there was pain but like I said the help of the motrin 800's really helped. (sorry for the spelling errors)
SAguy 14 Jun 2010
hi applescruff i have decided to go ur way and i must say it is every bit as pianfull as u said i started it about 2 hours ago so u can imagine the pain i'm feeling now anyway cross ur fingers for me and i hope it works 4 me aswell
applescruffs 14 Jun 2010
Good luck! In my personal opinion I think the rubber band is way better than the string because when the keloid starts to shrink, the rubber band is still tight and doesn't get loose like a string would. Therefor you dont have to keep restringing the keloid or worry about new blood mixing with the old blood causing infections. I'm keeping my fingers crossed for you! Just take pain meds and you'll be ok. I dont know why I didnt do this any sooner, my ear is normal again with a slight scar you dont see unless I point it out.
SAguy 18 Jun 2010
hi there today 18 june the keloid is now black, and has been so since yesterday afternoon,do I leave the rubber band on till it falls of or do i take it off b4 then?
applescruffs 22 Jun 2010
Wow!! Yours took 4 days to turn black just like mine did!! Thats great! I think you can take the rubber band off now (if you already didnt). I just got this email today but I see you posted it a couple days ago. I didnt put the rubber band back on after I took it off which was 4 days later. However, I have long nails so after the rubber band was off I would use my thumb nail and run it between the black keloid and ear lobe to kind of get it loose, but I didnt force it off or anything. The keloid was already separating from the ear so I was just giving it a hand. Make sure to put ointment on it after it falls off, or even now if its still attached. Maybe try using neosporen(?) so it doesnt scar too bad. Good Luck!!
SAguy 24 Jun 2010
IT'S OFF!!! but unlike yours i do have a hole behind my ear but it doesn't bother me, anyway im using germolene ointment on it and praying that it heals right. Thank you and everyone else that posted on this site, you all gave me the confidence to it MMMMMWWWWWAAAAAAHHHH lol.
b. perry 8 Feb 2012

i currently using the rubberband and the keloid is turning dark, but i was scared of the blood from the keloid getting in to my body(blood disease)how long will this take?

Lady Detroit 25 Mar 2010
Today oN March 26th is my face day for usingvthe string method and so far the keloids on both of my ears are turning purple! Is that normal? It has a slight discomfort to it but i am going to pull through this with alot of FAITH! Please respond and let me know if what i am going through on my first day is normal and i will keep everyone updated daily on my progress! Wish me luck and much success people...... THANK YOU
Lady Detroit 25 Mar 2010

i meant to say first day not face! lol...... this touchscreen phone is taking me sometime to get use to.

applescruffs 26 Mar 2010
As I've mentioned in my post above, yes it did turn purple for a couple of days, then it turned black. But I didnt use a string, I used a rubber band. Make sure to read Mike D's post above mine, since you are using a string. Good luck! My ear is 100% back to normal (what keloid?) lol
Lady Detroit 26 Mar 2010
Thank u for the advice and is headaches and neckpain associated with this procedure
Lady Detroit 26 Mar 2010
Also one of my keliods has started turning black already andtoday was the first day i did it! It has a small black spot on it so i guess i am doing this right! I am bearing with the pain with no medication and i am pullin through it with GOD'S grace. And i just wanted to say thank u all for the encouragement especially applecruff and mike d thank you guys so much just wish me luck and success on this journey
Lady Detroit 28 Mar 2010
Well it is day three of having these strings around my ears but i had to replace the strings with dental floss and one is almost completely black and the other one is half way black and continuning to turn black
destyni 11 Apr 2010
I am in the process of doing this now. I have a keloid on both of my ears. i tied string around them on april 5th. I woke up the next morning and they were extremely big with excruciating pain. I wanted to cry, but i took pain killers and toughed it out. I am noticing them getting looser and not so much attached to my ear. it is April 11th and i replaced the string tonight. They are not turning black but i do have some pus and very little bleeding. I did do this by myself and it hurts so very much, but if it works and they fall off it would be so worth it. I dont have insurance and definitely dont have hundreds maybe even thousands of dollars to get them removed just for them to possibly come back. Sleeping is hard to do now. i literally sleep on my chin. the smallest thing rubbing up against my keloids make them hurt. I will continue to update until i get these creatures to fall off.

Post a Comment

used for verification