I'm looking for a surgeon with a similar aesthetic as Dr. Vladimir Grigoryants but located in NYC

Those noses do NOT look natural! Are you sure that's the style you like!!?

The best rhinoplasty surgeon (according to before and after's, and reviews) in NYC that I found is Dr. Sam Rizk. The noses he "makes" look natural and drastically improved. That said, Sam Rizk is Sam Rizk, and not Dr. Grigoryants. If you want a specific surgeon, go to that surgeon. It would be worth it to fly out to get a procedure done instead of settling for someone in your area even when you are not 100% convinced that he/she is the right doctor for the job. Traveling to get plastic surgery done is not unheard of. There should be a special mention of out-of-towners on his website. I am lucky enough to live in the Glendale area and will choose Dr. Grigoryants for my rhinoplasty procedure, but I would have chosen to go to him even if I had lived abroad. Nobody does noses as beautifully as him and I think he will become the go-to guy for rhinoplasty in the future. Good luck, and I hope I could help a little.

It's hard to say that one doctor's work is like another's or that you'd be able to get a specific results, since rhinoplasty is so dependent on your own tissues and cartilage structure, etc., but you might want to start with a list of board certified plastic surgeons in your area and start researching them.