"Meaningful Beauty" lacks true meaning

Beauty Cred on 16 Jan 2007 at 12:00am

Meaningful Beauty review
Cindy Crawford has associated her beauty, name, and reputation to the “Meaningful Beauty” anti-aging skin care product line.
Cindy is obviously a natural beauty -- who denies ever getting Botox injections-- so we have to wonder, does Meaningful Beauty have true meaning?
Meaningful Beauty Ingredients
Meaningful Beauty is based on a formulation developed by French skin care expert, Dr. Jean-Louis Sebagh. What is the secret ingredient unearthed by Dr. Sebagh? Rare French melon. Sebagh believes some melons can defend our skin from the breakdown of collagen, which happens with age. Meaningful Beauty describes this ingredient as
“a rare French melon that stayed fresh and firm much longer than similar varieties. This melon contained a powerful “first generation” antioxidant (superoxide dismutase), which preliminary studies suggest, prevents the formation of new free radical species. By utilizing this first generation antioxidant, Meaningful Beauty's formulas are designed to help protect your skin against the visible signs of aging in a remarkable way.”
This is skin care, not science fiction
So why is the key Meaningful Beautiful ingredient referred to as a “rare French melon?” What is the name of the melon? Google the phrases “rare French melon” and “French melon” and the results offer limited help.  I found out that the French name for a cantaloupe is a “Charentais” melon, which is especially prized in France for its rich, honey finish. No word on its potent antioxidants, but the Meaningful Beauty website gives this answer on their FAQ’s page:
What kind of melon does Meaningful Beauty's patented melon extract come from? The patented melon extract in Meaningful Beauty’s revolutionary treatment products is taken from a rare form of "cantaloupe charentais", which is grown only in the south of France.
Does meaningful beauty work?
With a very beautiful woman attached to lure consumers, is Meaningful Beauty just a gimmick? Does it work? I think the commenters below are much more apt to reveal the truth than one person's opinion.
See also: Top 12 Celebrity Blondes
My opinion is it’s going to take a lot more than fruit to mimic the skin tone of one of the world’s most celebrated supermodels. I'd rather find my meaning in skin care products with more research to back up their claims.
Where can you buy Meaningful Beauty?
Meaningful Beauty is marketed by TV marketing pros Guthy Renker (home of Proactiv and Youthful Essence) as the “Complete Age Maintenance System." The line consists of a cleanser, moisturizer, night fluid, eye cream, masque and neck cream. Meaningful Beauty can be ordered as an introductory kit that gets you an automatic shipment every 90 days. 

Give us your opinion of Meaningful Beauty - -  Is it a scam that pulls you into a customer service nightmare? Or does Meaningful Beauty really work for you?

Comments (687)

Sort by

Fraud. Want cheap restorative cream? 2 portions coconut oil, 1 portion of shea butter, 5-10 drops of tea tree oil and 5-10 drops of argan oil. A little rose water to scent. Blend well (emulsify). Don't listen to scam fraud losers like Jean-Louis Sebagh who sell Botox and Plastic Surgery.
  • Reply
I used to get Meaningful Beauty several years ago but don't now. You can still get the products at Ulta at a higher price. If you are going to use all the products regularly the autoship program will save you money and I think you can call and skip a shipment or change the schedule. I'm pretty sure I did because I was unable to use that much in 90 days. Its I good product, but not a miracle worker. Due to my budget, my skin care comes from the grocery store now. I might pick up a bottle of serum at Ulta next time I have a splurge. It's not a scam just marketing as far as I know. If you combine all those products and buy the same types by say Olay or Loriel at the grocery you may spend more if you use them all up in a month or two. I don't so it's a better option for me. I had no problems cancelling my subscription.
  • Reply
why does one melon rot and the other not? are they not the same?
  • Reply
I wish there was a store that you could walk in and pick out what you wanted and needed in your moisturizers and such.....all natural, no harsh chemicals, and a real dermatologist helping you pick the right ingredients and amounts.
  • Reply
Two tablespoons of coconut oil, one tablespoon of shea butter, and a few drops of tea tree oil or argan oil. Blend well. A little dab will do it! Quite inexpensive, and all natural.
  • Reply
Interesting.  The shea doesn't make you break out? 
  • Reply
Just reread the original question and it should be majorly updated! Cindy Crawford HAS admitted to Botox injections and fillers, and other stuff. Earlier pictures can be seen online of Cindy with all kinds of sagging and aging skin on her belly (from children) and on her face. People made mean comments and not too soon after she appeared with a weird looking eye lift (it's a picture with Heidi Klum at fashion week a few years ago, for those looking for befores and afters.) PLEASE people! She is not superhuman, just a supermodel, and her skin sags and falls just like every forty-plus woman's....she just has waaay more help fixing it (thanks to the meaningFUL money thrown at meaningLESS beauty.)
  • Reply
It doesn't cause me any trouble at all. Very soft and smooth, but again, a little goes a long way.
  • Reply
I've often said to myself that I will, one day, buy ALL the BEST ingredients and make my own, strong, anti-aging moisturizer and I spoke to my Pharmacist about it and he said " you need to be careful because some of the ingredients have HIGH PH levels and you really need to be aware of that because you could be doing more harm than good to your facial skin. I also didn't know that some of the ingredients have to actually be " cooked " all together and then cool down to add more ingredients that would break down if cooked...it's complicated, but there have beeen a few times where I would add pure Vitamin E to whatever facial moisturrizer I was using at the time and I added it to give my moisturizer a BOOST because of how dry my face was after spending a day out in the sun during the summer, and I would first apply pure Aloe on my face and since it is like a " gel " I would wait for it to dry and then I would put on my moisturizer. I guess putting together all the natural ingredients of a moisturizer would not hurt your skin, it's when you might want to add some " Peptides " or some " Retinol " that would make it a bit more complicated. Ask your doctor or your pharmacist about it before you do anything just in case, you wouldn't want to put anything bad on your face and possibly get a bad reaction from it. Good luck !!! I would love to hear how it all turns out if you do decide to try to mix together your own moisturizer...here are a few links I've looked at in the past about making your own anti-aging moisturizer... truthinaging.com/review/make-your-own-anti-aging-face-cream.... This one is for just a regular, "plain" facial moisturizer... inhabitat.com/diy-make-your-own-all-natural-moisturizing-face-cream I guess you can purchase the ingredients you want in yourr moisturizer at any Health Store, like GNC or maybe your Pharmacist can tell you where a good place to buy the ingredients you want...Good Luck !!!
  • Reply
I called in December 20,2013 to cancel. We as of today 1/15/14 I haven't gotten an email saying I canceled. They are still taking money from me. I had to cancel my credit card. I have called 8 times. Cindy you should be ashamed of your self for having people work for you that don't care about how they treat your customers. I will be call the BBB. Please do not order anything from Cindy.
  • Reply
We have created a Meaningful Beauty community on RealSelf.  Write a review about your experience, post a discussion in the forum, and enjoy interacting with other Community Members!  You can find it here:

Meaningful Beauty Community or here http://www.realself.com/meaningful-beauty
  • Reply
-:- Message from RealSelf staff -:-

This comment does not follow our Community Guidelines and/or Terms of Service. We reserve the right to remove any post for any reason.
  • Reply
Is this product good for men?
  • Reply

Do you ever wonder. If you use products like this and then no longer use it does your face , neck, chest become more saggy ? In other words if you stop using what happens does it make matters worst?

  • Reply
Meaningful Beauty is mainly products with very good moisturizers and anti-oxidants, and Dr Sebagh's " super "melon" anti-oxidant " Superoxide Dismutase " ( SOD ) and this ingredient may be found in a melon in France but it is NOT that much of a secret...SOD is used in MANY " Anti-Aging" products...SOD is a powerful anti-oxidant that helps to reduce free radical oxidative damage and promotes cell reproduction of the skin tissue and regulates collagen and elastin formation to keep skin strong, smooth, and supple, BUT in order for it to regulate Collagen and Elastin, ( as we age our bodies slow down on the production of Collagen and Elastin so the use of " Anti Aging" products that have PEPTIDES are needed to be used....certin Peptides are very popular in Anti Aging products and they are proven to help the body produce Collagen and to help minimize fine lines and wrinkles and Meaningful Beauty unfortunately does NOT utilize these popular and effective Peptides in their products...they do have "some" peptides ,or peptide, in the serum and the moisturizer, but the peptides in Meaningful Beatuy's ' products are not as productive, not as strong, therefore they do not give the results as the more popular peptides that are proven to be effective when used in many other Anti Aging poducts ( brands ) ...SO if you stopped using Meaningful Beauty, your skin will get a bit "dry", not very moisturized very well if at all, and that's basically it because in my opinion, Meaningful Beauty is not a very good product for Anti Aging, it is basically just a group of products that have very good mooisturizers and anti-oxidants, but not the good variety of Peptides used for anti-aging benefits that MANY OTHER Cosmetic companies use...Save your money and buy yourself some Oil Of Olay Regenerist OR the Home Shopping Networks ( QVC, HSN, ShopNBC ) have some GREAT Cosmetic brands to choose from...I like HSN's ( HSN.com ) " Serious Skin Care " ...Jennifer Flavin Stallone ( Yes, Sylvester's wife ) is involved with this skin care line and they REALLY have some GREAT products !!! My mother uses their " Reverse Lift " line of products...they use a PEPTIDE that is known in the Cosmetic Industry as " Botox in a jar " but your face doesn't get that " paralyzed " look...it also has other peptides that help to produce collagen and very good anti-oxidants and moisturizers and it helps to firm and "lift" the face...gravity is nasty when you age !!! It also helps to rid fine lines and wrinkles and the entire kit consists of a firming cleanser, a firming serum, facial friming pads, a GREAT firming eye cream ( I use it because I have " hooded eyes "...that sagging skin between my upper eye lids and my eyebrows ) and after a month it , my eyes are SO MUCH BETTER, it helped to firm that sagging skin, and now I can see my eyelids without having to use my fingers to push, what used to be, that saggy skin between my upper eye lids and my eyebrows...it also comes with a chin and neck firming cream and a firming facial moisturizer and the whole kit is only $49.95 ( I think ) and I think you can make 4 or 5 or maybe even 6 monthly payments to pay it off with a credit card, and they have other anti-aging products too...I KNOW it's no more than $59.95, and my mother has been using it for over 6 months now and she LOVES it !!! Her face REALLY looks wonderful !!! She is, or she will be 69 on May 27th and her face looks as if she is in her early to mid 50 's and her confidence is as if she is in her 40's !!! ANYWAY, Good Luck with whatever you choose to use !!! :)
  • Reply
Read comment below re sulphates. Meaningful Beauty and many other products have this in them...not beneficial to your skin. You can do your research on them, and decide on a product that is sulphate-free and not being absorbed into your skin tissues..it's not a good additive.
  • Reply
Meaningful Beauty products are Full of sulphates, sulphates are commonly used in cosmetic cleansers, hair shampoos, bath and shower gels, bubble baths, etc. - It is probably the most dangerous ingredient used in skin and hair-care products. In the cleaning industry SLS is used in garage floor cleaners, engine degreasers, car-wash soaps, etc. It is very corrosive and readily attacks greasy surfaces. Sodium lauryl sulfate is used throughout the world for clinical testing as a primary skin irritant. Laboratories use it to irritate skin on test animals and humans so that they may then test healing agents to see how effective they are on the irritated skin. A study at the University of Georgia Medical College, indicated that SLS penetrated into the eyes as well as brain, heart, liver, etc., and showed long-term retention in the tissues. The study also indicated that SLS penetrated young children's eyes and prevented them from developing properly and caused cataracts to develop In adults. May cause hair loss by attacking the follicle. Classified as a drug in bubble baths because it eats away skin protection and causes rashes and infection to occur. Is potentially harmful to skin and hair. Cleans by corrosion. Dries skin by stripping the protective lipids from the surface so it can't effectively regulate moisture. ....When I initially ordered Meaningful Beauty, I asked if it had sulphates, I was told no. On receiving the order this is what the cleanser contains: Sodium Laureth Sulphate, Sodium Lareth B Sulfate, Magnesium Laureth d-Sulfate, Sodium Oleth Sulfate, Magnesium Oleth Sulfate...lets just add fertilizer to the mix! No mention of that natural exotic melon extract that the French Doctor mentioned in the TV ad.. Sulphates are in most store brands, however, there are many products out now without them. I would do your research, as it's important what goes on our skin and bodies. I would be surprised if CIndy actually uses this on her own skin. It's buyer beware, and don't forget Guenthy is a million dollar company out to push product, along with so many others. I have chosen to cancel furthur orders, and choose find a skin care line without the use of sulfates and surfactants.
  • Reply
Cindy should be ashamed of herself she is a fraud along with others who are involved.....they won't even abide by the 123 promo code Fraud I say!
  • Reply

You seem very informed..have you found a cream you like?

  • Reply
Cybcin, thanks for sharing. Seems like we have done the same research. I make it a habit not to purchase anything that is hawked by celebs. I feel that I am paying more for the product because of what they have to pay the celebs to hawk the product. I juice carrots and dab that on my face and it does a maginificant job on the age spots. You can see some results in several days. Otherwise, I use olive, grapeseed, coconut, etc oils from the market as a moistuerizer. I have been told that I look late 40/s but that was 30 yrs ago. My mantra...if you cannot eat it, do not put it on your body. And I would love to have a link to the site that Nadiahoney mentioned for creating your own stuff. DEV
  • Reply
hey devil's advocate -- it's skinscientist.com I THINK....or something to that effect. Some people use lotioncrafter.com. I never remember the name of it exactly but it's run by a woman named Hannah, a really smart, no nonsense scientist. REALLY smart. I was looking for vitamin C powder and how to make my own Skinceuticals and came across these types of sites on another site like realself. I don't know if I am supposed to name their "competition" so I won't, but it's similar in that you get the real deal about everything. There are several sites like skinscience, where you can buy your own cosmetic grade stuff to make and play with, but I just liked that one for lots of reasons, like how all these people are exchanging formulas and get to learn how each one works. NO ONE should have to spend a fortune on products that don't cost a fortune at all to make and Hannah debunks a LOT of the myths put out there about creme de la mer, the over-priced Dr. Brandt products, etc. She takes an exact list of ingredients from ANY product, explains what each of them does and how they work together, etc., and then even tells you how to make it BETTER. I am not kidding. I hate mixing stuff and cooking, so I buy the ones she has pre-made. I agree with you that when a celeb backs it, I learned the hard way to step back and think about what you are really paying for. Sometimes the product isn't bad, but sometimes it's utter b.s. like when Suzanne Somers was promoting the Thighmaster.....and then it came out that she had had liposuction on her thighs. Sorry, but I think the reason Cindy looks good is genetics, botox, fillers, and perhaps even a little eye tuck. I would bet the family farm Meaningful Beauty has next to nothing to do with it, and I suggest giving the exact ingredients to a biochemist and asking what's so great about it. Sounds like there's some glycolic acid involved, and that's very inexpensive. It works, but no need to put extra crap in it like sulfates.
  • Reply

I am 43 years old. Have been using meaningful beauty for over 3 years. I absolutely love the product, and find it very affordable. There are no products out there that aren't trying to make money off you, so you just have to find what works for you and your skin type.

  • Reply
GOOD LUCK if you want to cancel!!!!! My mom cancelled in July and they are still stealing $$$$$$ for products!! Getting your money back is proving to be a three month ordeal and yet no money yet!! Makes you wonder why Cindy Crawford would associate with a company with horrible shipping, customer service and ESPECIALLY BILLING DEPTS THAT NO ONE CARES AND TRYING TO GET A REFUND LASTS AS LONG AS A TRIMESTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • Reply
having same problem....
  • Reply
thanks for the validation NadiaHoney...Unfortunately i wasn't at Fashion Week to see her but that's just sad...women who live in that zip code are the most materialistic, phoney, insecure bunch of chicks on the planet...I watched an episode of "housewives from Beverly Hills"...THEY ALL HAD THE SAME FACE!!! Seriously, same nose, same cheeks, same lips, same hair color, same body...it's like the movie "The Stepford Wives" has come true...at least in that area of the world...no thanks. I am 54 and I am told daily that i dont look my age and I am so flattered but I know they are right. I don't !!l and it isn't because of any lotion, potion or surgical procedure. I just have good genes...
  • Reply